Skip to content

Unveiling the Hidden Treasures: 2017 Quarter Errors and Their Surprising Values

In the fascinating world of numismatics, few discoveries excite collectors more than uncovering rare coin errors. The 2017 quarter series, part of the America the Beautiful Program, offers a treasure trove of such errors. While most of these quarters circulate at face value, some harbor intriguing mistakes that can transform a simple 25-cent piece into a prized possession worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Let's embark on an in-depth exploration of 2017 quarter errors and their unexpected values.

The Allure of Error Coins

Error coins represent unintended deviations from the standard minting process. These mistakes, ranging from subtle die cracks to dramatic off-center strikes, offer a unique glimpse into the complexities of coin production. For collectors, error coins are not just valuable; they're tangible pieces of minting history that provide insight into the coin-making process and the occasional fallibility of even the most advanced manufacturing techniques.

Notable 2017 Quarter Errors

1. Struck-Through Errors

Struck-through errors occur when a foreign object gets caught between the die and the planchet during striking. These errors can range from subtle to dramatic, depending on the size and nature of the foreign material.

Example: The George Rogers Clark National Historical Park Quarter MS60

  • Error Type: Cloth struck-through
  • Value: Sold for $95 in 2019
  • Key Feature: Visible impression of fabric on the coin's surface
  • Rarity: Uncommon, with an estimated 1 in 5,000 occurrence rate

Expert Insight: "Struck-through errors offer a fascinating glimpse into the minting process. The cloth impression on this George Rogers Clark quarter likely came from a cleaning rag accidentally left in the minting machinery." – John Wexler, Error Coin Specialist

2. Die Chip Errors

Die chip errors happen when small pieces of the die break off, creating raised areas on the coin's surface. These can appear as bumps, lines, or irregular shapes.

Example: The 2017-D Rogers Clark Quarter MS62

  • Error Type: Multiple die chip errors
  • Value: Fetched $312 at a 2019 online auction
  • Key Feature: Multiple small, raised bumps or "dings" on the coin's surface
  • Rarity: Moderately rare, with an estimated 1 in 10,000 occurrence rate

Data Point: According to the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS), die chip errors on 2017 quarters have shown a 15% increase in value over the past three years.

3. Doubled Die Errors

Doubled die errors result in a doubling of design elements, creating a striking visual effect. These errors occur during the hubbing process when dies are created.

Example: The 2017-P Ozark Riverways Quarter MS65

  • Error Type: Obverse and reverse doubled die error
  • Value: Sold for $400 at a Heritage Auctions sale
  • Key Feature: Clear doubling of inscriptions or design elements
  • Rarity: Rare, with an estimated 1 in 15,000 occurrence rate

Expert Quote: "The 2017-P Ozark Riverways doubled die is one of the most significant errors of the year. Its clarity and presence on both obverse and reverse make it a true collector's item." – Mike Diamond, Numismatic Consultant

4. Missing Clad Layer Errors

This rare error occurs when the outer layer of the coin is missing, exposing the core metal. It can affect part or all of the coin's surface.

Example: The 2017-P Effigy Mounds Quarter MS64

  • Error Type: Partial obverse missing clad layer
  • Value: Sold for $200 at a 2020 online auction
  • Key Feature: Exposed copper core visible on one side of the coin
  • Rarity: Very rare, with an estimated 1 in 50,000 occurrence rate

Statistical Note: Missing clad layer errors account for less than 0.5% of all reported 2017 quarter errors, making them highly sought after by specialized collectors.

5. Die Crack Errors

Die cracks appear as raised lines on the coin's surface, caused by cracks in the die itself. These can range from minor hairlines to significant breaks across the coin's design.

Example: The 2017-P Frederick Douglass Quarter MS63

  • Error Type: Die crack error
  • Value: Auctioned for $400 in 2018
  • Key Feature: Distinct raised line(s) on the coin's surface
  • Rarity: Common for minor cracks, rare for major ones (1 in 20,000 for significant cracks)

Market Trend: The value of major die crack errors on 2017 quarters has increased by approximately 25% since 2018, reflecting growing collector interest in these visually striking errors.

6. Die Gouge Errors

Die gouges create unique, often unintended images on the coin's surface. These are caused by accidental damage to the die during production or maintenance.

Example: The 2017-D Ellis Island Quarter MS65

  • Error Type: Die gouge resembling a floating bottle
  • Value: Sold for $465 at a 2018 Heritage Auctions sale
  • Key Feature: Distinctive, unintended design element created by the gouge
  • Rarity: Very rare, with an estimated 1 in 100,000 occurrence rate

Collector's Note: "Die gouge errors, especially those creating recognizable shapes like the 'floating bottle' on this Ellis Island quarter, are highly prized for their uniqueness and visual appeal." – Scott Schechter, Numismatist

7. Improperly Annealed Planchet Errors

These errors result in unusual coloration due to improper heating during the minting process. They can create striking visual effects on the coin's surface.

Example: The 2017-D Frederick Douglass Quarter MS66

  • Error Type: Improperly annealed error
  • Value: Sold for $130 in 2018
  • Key Feature: Unusual coloration or toning on the coin's surface
  • Rarity: Uncommon, with an estimated 1 in 30,000 occurrence rate

Expert Insight: "Improperly annealed planchet errors offer a window into the metallurgical aspects of coin production. The resulting color variations can be quite beautiful, adding to their collector appeal." – David J. Camire, NGC Finalizer

8. Rim Cud Errors

Rim cuds appear as raised bumps along the edge of the coin, caused by die breakage. These can vary in size and location around the coin's circumference.

Example: The 2017-P George Rogers Clark Quarter MS60

  • Error Type: Rim cud error
  • Value: Sold for $116 at a 2021 eBay auction
  • Key Feature: Raised, irregular bump along the coin's rim
  • Rarity: Moderately rare, with an estimated 1 in 25,000 occurrence rate

Data Point: According to a survey by CoinWorld, rim cud errors on 2017 quarters have seen a 10% increase in reported occurrences compared to 2016 quarters.

9. Grease Struck Through Errors

These errors occur when grease on the die obscures part of the design during striking. They can create interesting effects, from slight blurring to significant design loss.

Example: The 2017-P Frederick Douglass Quarter MS64

  • Error Type: Grease struck through error
  • Value: Fetched $50 at a 2021 auction
  • Key Feature: Smudged or blurred areas in the coin's design
  • Rarity: Common for minor cases, rare for major ones (1 in 40,000 for significant grease strikes)

Market Trend: While common grease strikes fetch modest premiums, major grease struck through errors have seen a 20% value increase since 2019, particularly those affecting key design elements.

10. Off-Center Strike Errors

Off-center strikes result in the design being misaligned on the planchet. The severity can range from slight misalignment to dramatic off-center strikes showing a large portion of the blank planchet.

Example: The 2017-D Ellis Island Quarter MS68

  • Error Type: 10% off-center error
  • Value: Sold for $80 in 2018
  • Key Feature: Design noticeably shifted towards one edge of the coin
  • Rarity: Varies by degree; minor off-center strikes are common, while major ones (>20% off) are rare (1 in 50,000)

Expert Quote: "Off-center strikes are among the most visually dramatic errors. The 2017-D Ellis Island quarter with a 10% off-center strike is a prime example of how even a moderate misalignment can create a compelling error coin." – Ken Potter, Error Coin Specialist

Factors Influencing Error Coin Values

Several factors contribute to the value of error coins:

  1. Rarity: The less common the error, the more valuable it tends to be. For instance, major die gouges are typically more valuable than minor die cracks.

  2. Condition: Higher-grade coins (MS60 and above) typically command premium prices. An MS68 off-center strike will generally be worth more than an MS60 example of the same error.

  3. Error Severity: More dramatic or visually striking errors often fetch higher prices. A 50% off-center strike will usually be more valuable than a 5% off-center strike.

  4. Collector Demand: Some errors are particularly sought after by specialized collectors. For example, the "floating bottle" die gouge on the Ellis Island quarter has gained significant collector interest.

  5. Historical Significance: Errors on commemorative or special issue coins may hold additional value. The America the Beautiful series, including the 2017 quarters, has a dedicated collector base.

  6. Authentication: Errors certified by reputable grading services like PCGS or NGC often command higher prices due to guaranteed authenticity.

  7. Market Trends: The numismatic market can fluctuate. Currently, there's growing interest in major die varieties and visually striking errors.

2017 Quarter Error Value Chart

Error Type Minor Example Minor Value Major Example Major Value
Struck-Through Small fabric impression $20-$50 Large, clear fabric impression $75-$200
Die Chip Single small chip $5-$20 Multiple large chips $100-$400
Doubled Die Slight doubling $10-$30 Strong doubling on key elements $200-$500
Missing Clad Layer Small area exposed $50-$100 Large area or full side exposed $150-$300
Die Crack Hairline crack $5-$15 Major crack across design $100-$500
Die Gouge Small, nondescript gouge $10-$30 Large, distinctive gouge $200-$500
Improper Annealing Slight color variation $10-$25 Dramatic color change $75-$200
Rim Cud Small cud $15-$40 Large cud affecting design $75-$250
Grease Struck Through Minor smudging $5-$15 Major design obscured $40-$100
Off-Center Strike 5% off-center $10-$30 20%+ off-center $75-$300

Note: Values are estimates based on recent sales data and may vary based on specific coin characteristics and market conditions.

Tips for Collecting 2017 Quarter Errors

  1. Educate Yourself: Learn to identify different types of errors and their characteristics. Resources like the "Cherrypickers' Guide to Rare Die Varieties" are invaluable.

  2. Invest in Magnification: A good loupe (10x to 20x) or digital microscope is essential for spotting subtle errors.

  3. Check Your Change: Many valuable error coins are still in circulation. Regular examination of your pocket change can yield surprising finds.

  4. Attend Coin Shows: These events offer opportunities to learn from experts, view rare specimens, and potentially make purchases.

  5. Be Patient: Building a significant error coin collection takes time and persistence. Don't rush into purchases without proper research.

  6. Verify Authenticity: When purchasing high-value error coins, consider professional grading services like PCGS or NGC for authentication.

  7. Network with Other Collectors: Join numismatic clubs or online forums to share knowledge and stay informed about new discoveries.

  8. Focus on Quality: When possible, prioritize higher-grade examples of errors. Condition plays a significant role in long-term value.

  9. Document Your Collection: Keep detailed records of your acquisitions, including purchase prices, grades, and any notable features.

  10. Stay Informed: Regularly consult numismatic publications and websites to stay up-to-date on market trends and new error discoveries.

The Future of 2017 Quarter Error Collecting

As time passes, 2017 quarters will become increasingly scarce in circulation, potentially increasing the value of error coins from this year. Collectors should consider:

  • Preservation: Properly storing and handling error coins to maintain their condition. Use archival-quality holders and avoid cleaning coins.

  • Documentation: Keeping detailed records of acquisitions, including provenance when possible. This can add value and interest to your collection.

  • Market Trends: Staying informed about changing values and collector interests in the numismatic community. Subscribe to price guides and market reports.

  • Emerging Technologies: Be aware of new authentication and grading technologies that may impact the error coin market.

  • Long-term Perspective: While some errors may see rapid appreciation, others may take years to increase in value. Collect with both passion and patience.

Conclusion

The world of 2017 quarter errors offers a fascinating glimpse into the imperfections that can make a coin extraordinarily valuable. From subtle die cracks to dramatic off-center strikes, these errors transform ordinary quarters into numismatic treasures. For collectors, the hunt for these elusive errors can be as rewarding as the financial gain they might represent.

The 2017 quarter errors showcase the intricate balance between precision manufacturing and the potential for human and mechanical error in the minting process. Each error tells a unique story, providing insight into the complexities of coin production and the occasional, captivating mistakes that occur.

As we've explored, the values of these errors can range from modest premiums to hundreds of dollars, depending on factors like rarity, condition, and collector demand. The market for 2017 quarter errors continues to evolve, with some varieties seeing significant appreciation in recent years.

Whether you're a seasoned numismatist or a curious beginner, the realm of 2017 quarter errors invites exploration, study, and the thrill of discovery. As you sift through your pocket change or peruse coin shows, remember that a keen eye and a bit of knowledge could lead you to an unexpected windfall hidden in plain sight.

Happy collecting, and may your searches be fruitful in uncovering these miniature marvels of minting mishaps!