In the world of numismatics, few coins capture the imagination quite like the Morgan silver dollar. Among these, the 1886 issue holds a special place, with some specimens commanding astonishing prices at auction. But what makes an 1886 silver dollar truly rare and valuable? Let's dive into the fascinating world of these historic coins and uncover the factors that can turn a seemingly ordinary piece of currency into a numismatic treasure.
The Morgan Dollar: A Brief History
Before we delve into the specifics of the 1886 issue, it's important to understand the context of the Morgan dollar series:
- First minted in 1878, following the Coinage Act of 1873
- Designed by George T. Morgan, hence the name
- Produced until 1904, then again in 1921
- Revived for collectors in 2021 to commemorate the centennial
The 1886 Morgan dollar sits squarely in the middle of this iconic series, benefiting from refined minting processes while still retaining the charm of early production years.
1886 Morgan Dollar Mintage Figures
To appreciate the rarity of certain 1886 dollars, we must first look at the mintage figures:
| Mint Location | Mintage | Mint Mark |
|---|---|---|
| Philadelphia | 19,963,000 | None |
| New Orleans | 10,710,000 | O |
| San Francisco | 750,000 | S |
| Proof (Philadelphia) | 886 | None |
At first glance, these numbers might not seem particularly low. However, the story of rarity unfolds when we consider survival rates and condition.
What Makes an 1886 Silver Dollar Rare?
Several factors contribute to the rarity and value of an 1886 Morgan dollar:
1. Mint Mark and Condition
- Philadelphia (No Mint Mark): While common in lower grades, examples in MS-67 or better are scarce. According to PCGS Population Report, only 36 coins have been graded MS-67, with none finer.
- New Orleans (O): Extremely rare in high grades, especially MS-65 and above. PCGS has certified only 12 coins in MS-65, with a mere 3 in MS-66.
- San Francisco (S): The lowest mintage of the year, with high-grade specimens being particularly valuable. PCGS reports 89 coins in MS-65, but only 9 in MS-66.
2. Strike Quality
- Well-struck coins with full detail are more desirable, especially for the New Orleans mint.
- "Proof-like" (PL) and "Deep Mirror Proof-like" (DMPL) surfaces command significant premiums. For instance, an 1886-O DMPL in MS-65 sold for $223,250 in a 2019 auction.
3. Die Varieties and Errors
- Doubled dies, especially on the obverse, can increase value significantly. The 1886 VAM-1A "Doubled Date" variety can command a 20-30% premium in high grades.
- Other errors like clashed dies or multiple strikes are prized by specialists. An 1886 "Clashed Obverse" variety in MS-65 sold for $4,800 in a recent auction, compared to $3,200 for a regular strike in the same grade.
4. Preservation
- Coins that have avoided cleaning, harsh environmental conditions, or damage are increasingly rare.
- Original mint luster is highly prized, particularly on New Orleans-minted coins. An 1886-O with full cartwheel luster can sell for double the price of a typical example in the same grade.
The 1886-O: A Prime Example of Conditional Rarity
The 1886-O Morgan dollar perfectly illustrates the concept of conditional rarity. While over 10 million were minted, finding high-grade examples is exceedingly difficult:
| Grade | PCGS Population | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| MS-60 | 923 | $400 |
| MS-63 | 334 | $2,500 |
| MS-64 | 82 | $15,000 |
| MS-65 | 12 | $125,000 |
| MS-66 | 3 | $400,000+ |
This disparity is due to several factors:
- Poor striking quality at the New Orleans mint
- Extensive circulation
- Lack of numismatic interest at the time of minting
The 1886-S: Low Mintage Meets High Demand
With only 750,000 minted, the 1886-S is naturally scarcer than its Philadelphia and New Orleans counterparts. Key points include:
- More valuable than the 1886 and 1886-O in all grades
- Particularly desirable in MS-65 and above
- Proof-like specimens are highly sought after
| Grade | PCGS Population | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| MS-63 | 1,241 | $650 |
| MS-64 | 678 | $1,000 |
| MS-65 | 89 | $6,500 |
| MS-66 | 9 | $35,000 |
Proofs: The Ultimate 1886 Rarity
With only 886 minted, proof 1886 Morgan dollars are inherently rare. However, their value is further enhanced by:
- Exceptional striking quality
- Mirrored fields and frosted devices (known as "cameo" effect)
- Historical significance as specially prepared collector pieces
| Grade | PCGS Population | Estimated Value |
|---|---|---|
| PR-64 | 112 | $4,000 |
| PR-65 | 134 | $5,500 |
| PR-66 CAM | 41 | $12,000 |
| PR-67 DCAM | 12 | $40,000+ |
Assessing Your 1886 Silver Dollar
If you believe you have a valuable 1886 Morgan dollar, consider these steps:
-
Determine the mint mark: Look for an "O" or "S" below the wreath on the reverse. No mint mark indicates Philadelphia.
-
Assess the condition: Look for signs of wear on the high points (Liberty's hair, eagle's breast feathers).
-
Check for luster: Original mint luster is a key factor in determining grade and value.
-
Look for errors or varieties: Use a magnifying glass to check for doubling or other unusual features.
-
Avoid cleaning: Even gentle cleaning can significantly reduce a coin's value.
-
Seek professional grading: For potentially valuable coins, third-party grading can provide an objective assessment and protection.
Market Trends and Investment Potential
The market for high-grade 1886 Morgan dollars, particularly from New Orleans and San Francisco, has shown strong growth in recent years. Factors driving this trend include:
- Increasing interest in classic U.S. coins
- Growing appreciation for conditional rarity
- Limited supply of top-grade specimens
According to the PCGS3000 Index, which tracks the value of key-date Morgan dollars, prices for high-grade 1886-O and 1886-S coins have increased by an average of 7% annually over the past decade.
Expert Insights
As a seasoned US coin collecting expert, I've observed several trends specific to 1886 Morgan dollars:
-
Toning Premium: Beautifully toned 1886 Morgans, especially those with vibrant rainbow colors, can command significant premiums. A recent auction saw an MS-65 1886 with exceptional toning sell for $8,400, nearly double the price of a typical MS-65.
-
Certification Importance: The gap in value between raw and certified coins continues to widen. A raw 1886-O in apparent MS-63 condition might sell for $1,000, while a PCGS or NGC certified MS-63 could fetch $2,500 or more.
-
Variety Collecting: Interest in VAM varieties (named after Leroy C. Van Allen and A. George Mallis) has surged. The 1886 VAM-1A "Doubled Date" and VAM-21 "Gouge Under 6" have seen particular growth in collector demand.
-
Proof-like Premiums: The market for proof-like and deep mirror proof-like 1886 Morgans has strengthened considerably. An 1886-S DMPL in MS-64 recently sold for $12,000, compared to $1,000 for a regular strike in the same grade.
Conclusion: The Enduring Allure of the 1886 Morgan Dollar
The 1886 Morgan silver dollar exemplifies the complexity and fascination of numismatics. From the surprisingly rare high-grade New Orleans specimens to the low-mintage San Francisco issues and the elusive proofs, these coins offer something for collectors at every level.
Whether you're a seasoned numismatist or just beginning to explore the world of coin collecting, the 1886 Morgan dollar provides a window into American history, artistry, and the ever-evolving nature of rarity and value in the collector market. As you examine these coins, remember that each one tells a story – of the mints that produced them, the people who used them, and the collectors who have treasured them for over a century.
In the end, the true value of an 1886 silver dollar lies not just in its monetary worth, but in the passion it inspires and the connection it provides to our numismatic heritage. Happy collecting!
