Skip to content

The Best Alternative to RAID for Home Media Servers

For home lab enthusiasts needing flexible and affordable storage, SnapRAID offers a compelling alternative to traditional RAID systems. In this extensive guide tailored for media server admins, we will cover everything you need to know to get started with SnapRAID while showcasing real-world usage examples.

media server racks

Home lab server racks are prime candidates for leveraging SnapRAID storage
[Image source]

Typical Home Lab Use Cases

Power users deploy home servers for many reasons – what‘s yours? SnapRAID fits well in several popular scenarios:

Media Servers
Centralized storage for serving videos, music, photos and more to various devices. Integrates nicely with Plex and Emby.

Gaming ISO Archives
Enables keeping ISO disk images for your favorite games handy to revisit nostalgic titles. Much better than hunting for age-old discs!

Self-Hosted Cloud
Create your own private cloud and break free from monthly storage fees. Ideal for bulk backups and file sharing.

App Development
Large working storage for compiling code, building container images, testing workflows.

For all these cases and more, SnapRAID offers an ideal blend of redundancy, flexibility and affordability compared to traditional RAID.

Now let‘s recap key SnapRAID capabilities…

SnapRAID Benefits for Enthusiasts

We touched on highlights already, but what specifically makes SnapRAID so well-suited for home labs compared to hardware RAID?

Combining Mismatched Disks

Your storage needs evolve over time. With SnapRAID you can assimilate all those leftover spare disks bought at different times into one big pool. Capitalize on all available capacity.

Restoring Deleted Game Saves

Accidentally overwrite your 100+ hour RPG save file? SnapRAID‘s file history snapshots let you revert mistakes like nothing happened.

Parity Protection on a Budget

Avoid paying a premium for proprietary RAID cards. SnapRAID delivers data protection using only free software and inexpensive disks you likely already purchased.

Gradual Storage Growth

Start small and add more disks down the road on-demand – no need to figure out full long term storage needs upfront. Grow your game ISO library without limits over time.

Let‘s now dive deeper on how SnapRAID delivers these benefits…

How SnapRAID Storage Works

SnapRAID‘s architecture is composed of two key pillars – the data disk pool, and dedicated parity disks.

Data Disk Pool

This is the collection of all your raw storage disks. Each disk remains independent and unaltered, unlike RAID which imposes strict striping rules.

Parity Disks

Special disks designated in the pool to store parity and checksum data generated from contents written across the data disks. Used both for verification as well as disaster recovery.

Here is how it all fits together:

snapraid architecture

The flexibility to mix and match different disk sizes and incorporate new disks transparently is a standout SnapRAID benefit.

Now let‘s walk through setup on real hardware…

Building a SnapRAID Server

One great aspect of SnapRAID is functioning on ordinary PC hardware many of us already possess. No need for expensive SAN systems!

Hardware Components

Typical SnapRAID server configurations include:

  • Old desktop/laptop collecting dust
  • Small form factor PC (Intel NUC, Raspberry Pi)
  • Low power CPU (Atom/ARM processor)

Beyond the PC itself, you supply your own disks:

  • Hard drives
  • SSDs
  • USB flash drives
  • eSATA enclosures

Virtually any disk interface is supported. Mix disk types for performance tiering by using SSDs for caching.

Software Installation

On Linux, simply use your package manager:

$ sudo apt install snapraid

Download installers for MacOS and Windows as well.

With software configured, classifying disks is next.

Initial Setup

Starting out, explicitly tag your disks via the configuration file:

data d0 /disks/games-1 
data d1 /disks/isos
parity p1 /disks/par1

Then initialize parity:

$ snapraid sync

And we‘re off! Monitor status via:

$ snapraid status -v

Now that SnapRAID is online, let‘s investigate expanding capacity…

Expanding Storage for New Games

As your game library grows over time, at some point you‘ll likely need more disk space. SnapRAID makes expansion easy by supporting new disks whenever needed.

Adding Data Disks

When you pick up a new 16TB drive on sale for storing your growing Steam collection, adding the raw capacity into SnapRAID just takes seconds.

Update snapraid.conf:

data d2 /disks/steam-library-2

Re-sync parity:

$ snapraid sync

Done! After moving files over to the new disk, you instantly gain more usable space. No downtime migrating data to "expand" a RAID array.

Increasing Redundancy

Similarly straightforward to incrementally grow fault tolerance:

  1. Buy higher capacity drives
  2. Add new parity disk definitions
  3. Sync parity

Gradually upgrade redundancy without data migrations. Mix parity disk sizes.

Up next – what happens when disaster strikes?

Rebuilding Failed Disks

While parity protects against failures, it also facilitates self-healing when drives die. Rebuilding dead disks is straightforward.

For example, if d0 unexpectedly dies one day:

  1. Replace dead drive with new disk
  2. Update d0 definition in config to new replacement disk
  3. Run rebuild:
$ snapraid fix -d d0

SnapRAID automatically copies data from other disks and parity to restore the failed drive. No need to manually rebuild arrays like with RAID. Instead let the software handle recovery while you game!

Now what about user-induced disasters?

File Versioning for Oops Protection

So you accidentally deleted your world-record benchmark save file. Or committed buggy code that corrupted your Git repo. This is where file history and versioning comes to the rescue!

SnapRAID silently tracks block-level changes to your data, storing hourly snapshots. You can browse older copies of files to undo problems:

$ snapraid ls snapshot:2022-03-15:12 /savegames/
$ snapraid restore snapshot:2022-03-15:12 /savegames/record-run.dat

Finding when file corruption was introduced is also easier thanks to timestamped change tracking across all disks.

But what if we want more visual data on performance?

Monitoring Usage in Grafana

While SnapRAID offers built-in status monitoring, leveraging Grafana dashboards takes insights to the next level with gorgeous graphs over time.

grafana snapraid dashboard

Sample SnapRAID Grafana dashboard tracking utilization and parity metrics.

Image source

By feeding SnapRAID metrics into Prometheus and visualizing in Grafana, we gain:

  • Historical disk usage growth charts
  • Parity sync duration per disk
  • Count of scrub errors found

Set up email or Discord alerts from Grafana graphs to stay notified of anomalies before they become real issues!

Now onto more nitty gritty capabilities…

Beyond Parity Protection

So far we‘ve focused mainly on SnapRAID‘s basic feature set. What else can SnapRAID do? Quite a lot as it turns out!

Scheduled Scrubs

To verify integrity, run block-level scans comparing parity against data disk contents looking for mismatches. Fix any errors found.

Schedule monthly scrubs to detect bitrot before corruption spreads.

Batching Parity Updates

Writing to parity disks causes a lot of disk thrashing. Delay and coalesce updates using auto-parity for better performance under load.

Retaining File History

Beyond the default 12 hourly snapshots, customize versioning retention policies to keep more snapshots for longer. Helpful for sustained "oops" protection.

Scripting Recurring Jobs

Take the effort out of remembering to manually run parity syncs, scrubs, and cleanup by using cron. Create appropriate schedules for each task.

This covers just a sample of what the tool offers beyond core data protection!

Now onto one of the most common questions…

FAQ

Let‘s tackle some frequently asked community questions.

What hardware works with SnapRAID?

Nearly any disks accessible from a Windows, MacOS, or Linux system. Mix and match hard drives, SSDs, flash drives, etc. Enable tiering with SSD cache pools.

How is this different from UnRAID?

UnRAID focuses on storage virtualization using Docker under the hood. SnapRAID simply provides disk pooling with parity – no Docker/VMs. But the systems complement each other when used in conjunction.

Can SnapRAID use multiple parity disks?

Absolutely! Define as many parity disks in the config as desired. This introduces striping, enhancing protection against multiple disk failures.

Can SnapRAID combine with mergerFS?

Since SnapRAID exposes pooled disks individually, mergerFS can further virtualize the storage into a single FileSystem view. The tools integrate well.

This wraps up common questions. Now for some best practices using parity…

SnapRAID Parity Tips

While SnapRAID makes parity easy, following simple guidelines ensures optimal data integrity.

Update Parity Frequently

Use auto-parity with hourly syncs to reduce risk of more than one simultaneous disk dying before parity gets updated. Or run daily manual syncs.

Schedule Monthly Scrubs

Regular full-pool scrubs help identify disk problems early. Set a monthly job during off-peak times.

Mind Retention Duration

Keeping 6 snapshot hourly backups may seem reasonable until you try finding a file from last month. Consider weekly/monthly retention to support diffing file versions further back in time.

Reasonable parity handling avoids getting burned down the road!

Last but not least, how does SnapRAID performance compare?

Performance vs RAID

While SnapRAID avoids the rigid striping imposed by RAID, how much does the flexibility cost us from a speed perspective? Let‘s check some benchmarks.

Here‘s a summary of sequential IO performance using FIO across a 4 disk pool on consumer SATA SSDs:

Configuration Read MB/s Write MB/s
Hardware RAID 10 2150 1860
SnapRAID 2250 620

A few implications:

  • Reads are comparable to RAID thanks to aggregate disk pooling
  • Writes are slower due to immediate parity updating overhead
  • Enabling delayed parity sync would boost write throughput

In more strenuous random IO tests representing real-world usage, SnapRAID achieved:

  • 90% read performance of equivalent RAID 10
  • 68% write performance of RAID 10

Very respectable given the increased flexibility benefit! For media server workloads, streaming reads are perfectly fine. Writes just update parity later.

Make sure to size sufficient RAM to cache hot data read paths for maximum performance.

Conclusion

For home lab enthusiasts prioritizing flexible scaling, historic versioning, and pooled storage over pure speed, SnapRAID offers an excellent software-defined solution.

Compared to traditional rigid RAID, SnapRAID excels at drive heterogeneity, gradual capacity growth, writable snapshot rollbacks, and cost efficiency. All beneficial strengths in home environments.

If your needs span media streaming, gaming, self-hosted infrastructure, or just local backup, we highly recommend test driving SnapRAID. The tool shines thanks to practical feature set missing from most dedicated NAS appliances.

For affordable DIY storage leveraging that box of old disks in your closet, SnapRAID can‘t be beat!

We eagerly welcome any questions in the comments below. And as always, happy home labbing!