Skip to content

The 5 Best Baseball Games for a PC in 2023

Baseball video games allow fans to experience the sport in new and exciting ways. With the customization, variety of game modes, and ability to manage a franchise, baseball games are extremely popular for PC gamers. This article will highlight the 5 best baseball video games you can play on a Windows PC this year.

Key Features of Great Baseball Games

When evaluating baseball video games, some important features include:

  • Graphics and Animation: Smooth, realistic graphics make the players and stadiums feel lifelike. Good animation is key for batting, pitching, and fielding.
  • Game Modes: The ability to play exhibition games, full seasons, franchise mode, career mode, and online versus other players provides variety.
  • Customization: Editing player skills, abilities, uniforms, logos, and stadiums allows you to craft a unique experience.
  • Gameplay Depth: Complex controls, strategies, and AI challenge hardcore baseball fans.
  • Accessibility: Easy to pick up and play for baseball novices. Tutorials and difficulty levels welcome new players.

Keeping these key features in mind, here are the top baseball video games on PC right now:

#1. Super Mega Baseball 4

Super Mega Baseball 4 is an arcade-style game focusing on over-the-top baseball action. With superb batter-pitcher battles, physics-based hitting, and dazzling defensive plays in the field, SMB4 is simply a blast to pick up and play.

The variety of exhibition, season, franchise, and online modes provides plenty of content to keep you coming back. Customization options give you control over your team logo, uniform, ballpark, and even umpire behavior! SMB4 runs smoothly on a wide range of PC rigs too.

Over 200 Mash It Baseball legends like Vladimir Guerrero, Ozzie Smith, and Johnny Damon lend their talents to the game. Overall, if you want an accessible, lighthearted baseball simulation with depth for both casual and competitive gamers, SMB4 is a home run!

Pros: Fantastic arcade-style gameplay, four robust game modes, full customization suite, online league support, runs on most PCs

Cons: Lacks official MLB licensing and some small graphical glitches

Super Mega Baseball 4 cover

#2. Out of the Park Baseball 24

Out of the Park Baseball 24 is the premier baseball management simulation franchise. OOTP 24 gives you unparalleled control over an MLB organization, with sole responsibility for trades, draft strategy, lineups, pitching staff, minor league systems, and budgets.

The sheer depth of managing every aspect of a baseball club is staggering. Historical and fictional leagues with real MLB players, officially licensed logos, and over 200,000 playable characters will keep franchise mode interesting for eons. The community creates updates, mods, and even entirely new parks and leagues too.

For statheads who want to evaluate every metric down to triple-A reliever ERA, master the waiver wire, and micromanage player development, OOTP 24 is a dream. Just brace yourself for the steep learning curve!

Pros: Incredible franchise management depth, official MLB licensing, huge community with custom content

Cons: Extremely complex with tough learning curve, not pick-up-and-play

Out of the Park Baseball 24 cover

#3. BASEBALL STARS 2

BASEBALL STARS 2 offers a nostalgic, retro baseball experience. Originally launching on the NES in 1992 before coming to PC in 2016, BASEBALL STARS 2 features pixel art graphics and gameplay reminiscent of baseball‘s 8- and 16-bit era.

The simplicity compared to modern simulations is part of the charm! The core game has you battling AI opponents in tournaments, season mode sees your squad playing over 100 games, and local multiplayer with friends splits the screen for competitive two-player action.

On the diamond, BASEBALL STARS 2 adds nice enhancements like defensive positioning shifts and substitutions you can set for pitchers and bench players. It captures the essence of baseball‘s golden age in video games. Check it out for a change of pace from simulations and modern titles.

Pros: Retro pixel art style, local multiplayer support, large season mode

Cons: No online play, simplistic mechanics, lacks modern game modes

Baseball Stars 2 cover

#4. Baseball Mogul 2023

For a more modern baseball management experience than Out of the Park Baseball, check out Baseball Mogul 2023. You take the reigns of a franchise as the GM, building your MLB organization through trades, draft picks, promotions, and financial decisions.

Baseball Mogul impresses with its wealth of historical MLB data to enhance realism. Over 76,000 players, draft results dating back decades, and 102 years of historical game results, World Series winners, and more provide context to every season.

Unique to Baseball Mogul is the ability to make in-game decisions during gameplay itself as the manager, not just solely as a front office. Set lineups, call for steals and bunts on offense, and select pitches and defensive positioning on the mound and in the field during games!

For a management challenge blending baseball history and executive decisions with in-game involvement, Baseball Mogul 2023 is fantastic. The presentation keeps you playing into the postseason year after year.

Pros: Huge amount of historical data, manager mode for gameplay decisions, simpler than OOTP

Cons: Occasional roster errors, confusing menus

Baseball Mogul 2023 cover

#5. MLB Home Run Derby VR

For baseball fans seeking a wholly different and modern experience, MLB Home Run Derby VR uses virtual reality technology for an immersive batting game. Officially licensed by Major League Baseball, Home Run Derby allows you to smash homers in all 30 MLB ballparks!

Clubs and stadiums sport realistic designs true to their real-life counterparts. Facing off derby-style against MLB pitching legends or your friends locally, your goal is to crush as many home runs as possible to climb the derby leaderboards!

Swing for the fences across nine innings to set distance records, with power-ups randomly appearing for perks like freezing the pitcher or doubling your homer distance. The tracking works well, making solid contact on pitches incredibly satisfying. If you own a VR headset for PC, definitely give MLB Home Run Derby a look for some dingers!

Pros: Officially licensed by MLB, experience hitting in 30 parks in VR, fun derby modes

Cons: Requires VR headset, lacks non-derby game modes

MLB Home Run Derby VR cover

Wrapping Up the Best Baseball Games on PC

From modern hits like Super Mega Baseball 4 to retro classics like Baseball Stars 2 and everything in between, excellent baseball video game options for PC exist covering different genres, visual styles, and features.

Arcade-style, simulation, management, and even VR games let you experience the essence of baseball in creative ways. Whether you want fast-paced action or hardcore management depth, bats are swinging on computers!

Now grab some popcorn and peanuts and enjoy America’s pastime on the virtual diamond. Let me know on social media about your favorite baseball video games on PC!