Skip to content

Starfield Review: A Spoiler-Free Analysis from a Passionate Game Voyager


My journey into the unknown awaits

As someone who has sunk thousands of hours into Bethesda’s rich open world RPGs, I’ve eagerly awaited Starfield’s launch for years. Now having spent quality time charting my course through its systems and stars, I’m pleased to report this sci-fi saga both fulfills that signature BGS exploration while elevating areas once considered weaknesses. Is everything pitch perfect? Of course not – some pesky bugs still slip aboard. But between the alien vistas begging to be discovered, faction stories riddled with moral quandaries, genuinely great writing and voice acting, truly player driven progression and an excellent value proposition? Sign this space cowboy up for the long haul.

While comparisons to Skyrim in space floated about, that sells the expert worldbuilding short. Starfield stands firm in its identity as a grounded sci-fi setting rather than high fantasy. Beyond the stars lies mystery instead of magic, but the allure of exploration into the unknown remains unmatched. Let’s break things down beyond the stratosphere.

Enter a Bold New Universe

Transporting players over 300 years into the future during 2330 AD, *Starfield* kicks off when scientists finally crack viable faster-than-light space travel, enabling migration from Earth for resource harvesting and colonization efforts. This ushers in rapid expansion across the galaxy – though instability and perils arise outside Sol’s protection.

As an independent freelancing spacefarer, my own path gradually builds fame (and notoriety) by aiding various factions through tasks appropriate for a roguish Han Solo type with eclectic skills. Between responding to distress calls, investigating derelict space hulks, smuggling illegal artifacts, or hunting pirates for bounties though, overarching mysteries emerge that propel the main storyline forward in unexpected directions.

Ultimately four primary factions steer events based on their competing interests and philosophies:

  • United Colonies act as the central governance and defensive force struggling to safeguard swollen territories from external threats both alien and human. Militaristic expansionists project strength through fleets and mech-equipped troops.

  • Freestar Collective fights injustice through disruption, providing outlaw havens welcoming diverse cultures and beliefs rejected by the establishment. Ragtag freedom fighters value liberty from tyranny above all.

  • Ryujin Industries wield diplomacy guiding corporate interests, in the name of stability and prosperity… by any means necessary. Savvy industrialists hide cutthroat agendas.

  • Crimson Fleet embraces scientific exploration and progressive ideals to lead humankind into the future. Intrepid academics commit war crimes for the greater good.

Navigating tensions between these ideological power players drives much of the branching narrative. Beyond influencing my reputation however, faction alignments also unlock unique gear and ships while impacting the game’s climax, adding replay incentive. It takes time to fully grasp motivations and nuances through gleaning intel from incoming transmissions and completing aligned contracts though.

Who holds the moral high ground? As threats encroach and stakes rise ever higher, even I struggled at times discerning fact from manipulative propaganda. Grizzled leaders hide uncomfortable truths and haunted pasts. Truly no heroes exist out here – just realistic individuals and groups following agendas shrouded under pressure in the endless void. Some revelations hit hard, while certain decisions had me sitting in silence weighing outcomes.

This plays right into the emphasis on developing your character‘s identity through an exploratory conversational dialog system. Certain responses flow closer to diplomatic, snarky, professional or impatient flavors for example. My smuggler evaded and bluffed his way through many exchanges which proved quite entertaining. It‘s no replacement for a full speech check system still, but enhances roleplaying.

Custom Characters & Gameplay

Let’s transition towards discussing my smuggler Captain Drake’s progression and activities venturing the spaceways more directly. Upon embarking from my backwater homestead, the character creator offers just enough cosmetic flexibility through manipulating parents that final results appear pleasantly unique rather than awkward.

Beyond the strong facial animation and general quality art direction reinforcing this stage, the main attraction lies in assigning background traits and attributes. These not only influence starting gear and unlocked dialog options, but also provide gameplay advantages related to upgraded skills.

For instance, my interplanetary trader pedigree boosted profits when bartering while street smarts unlocked security system hacking. Hitting skill checkpoints then in turn unlocks perks across combat, social and exploration specialties. Everything synergizes through playstyle.

I focused heavily on boosting weapon crit damage then saving points once hangar upgrades unlocked Tier II ship modules. Installing an overcharged phaser cannon and particle accelerator to shred enemy hulls made battles exponentially smoother. Especially when later captain perks enabled auto-repairing damage mid-fight without chems.

Adding bonuses to dialogue skill checks and resource detection range served my scavenger tendencies well too. Maxing out the intimidate perk sufficiently boosted success rates when demanding additional payment for contract work. Fear my spaceship! All this character building feeds right back into the core gameplay loop.

The freedom to play precisely how you want stands unmatched in the genre. Rely exclusively on smarts to hack security mechs? Go full space pirate strictly ambushing haulers for profit? Maybe attempt a no-kill “Star Trek” approach upholding utopian ideals through science and diplomacy? Perhaps even stealthily infiltrate bases via secret passages to nab treasure, only engaging foes when mandatory?

Starfield welcomed my preferred morally grey explorer roaming at my own pace. Yes, sometimes I stumbled into fights woefully under-leveled, but quick wits and 400hp of shielding bought escape time to recover. The flexibility shown towards player agency deserves applause.

Spaceships & Combat

The heartbeat behind this entire experience thrives aboard our trusty starships. These vessels act as mobile bases from which to launch various adventures whether combat, resource harvesting or travel. While initial handling and traversal confused me somewhat, incremental upgrades whether improving top speed, boost regen delay or installing afterburners to outrun danger smoothed proceedings appropriately.

Combat itself appears deceptively simple on the surface. Similar to standard FPS run-and-gun strafing with a mixture of ballistic, laser and plasma weapons. Except enemies now feature multiple layers of shielding and armor separated by type and body area that demand targeted component destruction to maximize damage. Higher difficulties punish sloppy positioning and timing severely thanks to aggressive flanking and dense numbers. Prioritizing mods boosting armor penetration and critical hit damage helped cut through harder targets once weapon skills reached Master levels.

Destroyed shield emitters or thruster components expose weak points ripe for surgical strikes too. This requires balancing maximizing DPS output with paying attention to enemy barriers dropping amidst the laser lightshow to capitalize on vulnerability windows. kiting and breaking line of sight still works wonders for sustaining shield integrity as well against overwhelming numbers.

Is everything flawless though? Far from it. Cover mechanics get sacrificed by the second-to-second mobility, creating situations where smoothed combat animations would shine. Certain enemy behavior sometimes glitches like frozen AI too, undermining intensity. But between dodging tracking missile swarms, blasting asteroids concealing turrets then slamming boots onto hostile freighters during boarding raids, the battle-tested Starfield gameplay loop engages wonderfully. Chasing that next exciting random encounter or loot drop remains highly compelling.

I carved a path to riches one destroyed space pirate hull at a time. Their loss, my exciting gain.

Beautiful, Dangerous Galactic Vistas

We play these games to get lost wandering alien landscapes, stumbling upon challenges earning memorable stories. Starfield’s dedication towards selling its macro sci-fi setting through environmental scope and attention to detail shows masterclass worldbuilding. Expect to minimum spend over 50 hours exploring even its tutorial zone. Let me elaborate on aspects driving immersion.

Planets themselves display staggering variety in biome, weather patterns, foliage and geological formations both on surfaces and underground revealing hidden abandoned labs suitable for diving into. Ice caverns stretch into darkness below tundra gusting violent blizzards that serve my penchant for collecting ingredients and rare mineral deposits. Exactly how extensive do these tunnel networks twist?

My obsessive scanning from orbit and cataloging local flora for bonuses ensured no secrets slipped past my watch either. Twilight alien auroras make perfect backdrops when discovering odd gravitational crystal formations granting temporary levitation effects. That time an ambush waiting team of snipers nearly doomed me still haunts though if I’m honest. Maybe I should exercise more caution instead of blind greed!

When the desolation wears down sanity, sprawling cities brimming with quests tied to my past catch rumor of lost technologies. The urban architectural sense and environmental narrative storytelling has never felt stronger for the team at Bethesda Game Studios. Though admittedly some textures still cry for upgraded resolution and objects can awkwardly clip or spawn oddly during landing sequences. Have to expect a few lingering janky artifacts. At least no terrifying incidents losing 50+ hours like Fallout 4 plagued me yet.

Stability concerns aside, just existing inside the world activates imagination. What colony civilization developed these crystalline megastructures coiling into the stratosphere? Should the gleaming skyscrapers abandoned here get restored or left entombed by storms once more? Even realizing the Starfield galaxy stays persistently simulated regardless of my presence or game state inspires. There’s still so much awaiting discovery out there beyond the horizon silently…I almost feel overwhelmed by scope realizing that fact. But no time like the present right? My trusty starship won’t fuel itself!


"We found an ocean planet today with such clear turquoise water, I swore humanity‘s best efforts back home modeled after cheap imitations…
***

Story Setting & Writing

Balancing the strong environmental focus lies equally strong writing quality and quest design. I half expected fetch quest drudgery akin to similarly expansive worlds, but nearly all side content links intelligently with regional lore and characters met organically beforehand, facilitating investment. Even miscellaneous tasks to install security monitoring devices or investigating signals from debris fields produce worthwhile narrative payoff via uncovered audio logs and derelict site exploration instead of solely existing to tick a reward checkbox.

The voice cast shines noticeably brighter than previous efforts as well across crucial NPCs. Lip syncing appears much tighter to facial animations, enhancing the illusion. Rather than stilted line reads falling flat amidst dead expressions sucking tension as with Fallout, I regularly found myself leaning closer during pivotal conversations genuinely unsure how events might unfold based on my response flavor and reputation modifiers. The cinematic dialogue camera appropriately frames characters instead of robotic medium shots too. Huge cudos to the directors because emotional resonance shows massive gains.

When an early mentor’s terrified transmission requesting aid got suddenly cut short after being ambushed, I immediately dropped 10+ active bounties mid-scrape to investigate and ensure her safety. Emergent bonds like that demonstrate how strong writing feeds player investment exponentially, achieving heightened awe and sadness compared to reading a generic note.

The dynamic world simulation accounts for your story choices sewing statuses forward as well – once angering a faction enough to spark a manhunt spree forcing me to constantly sleep aboard my ship while outlaw just to safely progress. Guards on sight would try apprehending through force before I learned disguising with uniforms. Immersive consequences emphasize thinking about decisions before acting.

That extends towards optional objectives during missions too. I accepted some shady contracts from Ryujin Industries manipulating settlements. But after witnessing firsthand their exploitative resource harvesting operations poisoning soil through runoff, flipping to support displaced resistance freedom fighters felt right. Now RIU guns for me whenever entering patrolled space after exposing their corrupt board to media groups. I lost perks and profitable trade routes because of that choice…however the colonists’ hope made up for it.

Definitive Verdict?

Is Starfield worth playing? After previewing the staggering amount of content and detail offered, absolutely. This stands strong as Bethesda Game Studios’ most ambitious vision yet that somehow feels familiar and comforting to explore all the same. Fans of open world RPGs and sci-fi themes need this immersive gem in their library for sure. Players seeking epic branching stories woven into faction conflicts and moral quandaries will find no better experience this decade either.

And somehow amidst all these staggering highs, it still manages to ship as a day one GamePass release. I’d easily value everything shown here at a full $70 price tag or more! Yet thanks to Microsoft we get immediate access bundled with their superb subscription. That generosity makes becoming ‘Starfield‘s biggest fan even easier.

Flaws naturally balance the shining strengths however. Travel relies on tedious warp jumps instead of proper manual flight between planets and systems. We’re stuck mostly hopping a couple hundred light years per loading screen instead of intuitively traversing space ourselves in vessels. Shame too since upgrades fine tune handling enough offering better immersion when dogfighting. Restricted access to galaxy sectors tied to campaign progress also somewhat hinders exploration paths early on.

Despite the greater emphasis on player freedom, I expect narrative sequences and quest prerequisites still funnel folks identically which disrupts emergent storytelling benefits during mid game sections. Not to mention lingering dated engine quirks around occasional lag, awkward animations and puzzled enemy behavior. To say nothing of likely game breaking community reported bugs awaiting patches! Building atop Creation does show limits in 2023, albeit understandable given the dated core.

But does any of that genuinely matter weighed against 200+ hours of brilliant worldbuilding, factions vying for power and the joy of procedural exploration as your customized character charts their own galactic legend one star at a time? For me and likely millions others come November 11th, a resounding no.

The promise of Starfield delivers tremendously. An easy recommendation for where to spend the next few hundred hours roleplaying among the stars.


My journey‘s just beginning

The destination awaits, space cowboy!


Final Verdict: 9/10

What I Loved

  • Massive scope full of discovery and adventure
  • Great writing and voice acting enhancing immersion
  • Deep character/ship builder encouraging specialization
  • Faction reputations impacting ending
  • Freedom to approach objectives creatively

What Could Improve

  • More populated cities and colonies
  • Refined travel between star systems
  • Smoother animations/presentation
  • Continuing to address lingering engine quirks