Smart TVs and Roku devices have emerged as two of the most popular platforms for streaming entertainment. With easy access to top streaming services like Netflix and Disney+, internet connected TVs have gone mainstream. But should you buy a smart TV or get a standalone streaming device like Roku? I compare the two options in detail to help you decide.
A Brief History
First, some background. Roku launched its first streaming player in 2008, pioneering the concept of inexpensive boxes that connect to TVs to enable streaming video from the internet. Being among the first movers in the space, Roku focused entirely on delivering a great streaming experience through partnerships with content providers.
Smart TVs emerged a few years later when manufacturers like Samsung and LG started building internet connectivity and apps directly into television sets. In addition to streaming video, smart TV platforms also let you access apps, play games, video chat, and control other smart devices. The software and apps on smart TVs are generally provided by the TV brands.
In both cases, the availability of high speed home internet networks paired with excellent wireless capabilities drove the rise of streaming devices and smart TVs. Today Roku remains a streaming focused company while smart TVs pack in many smart functionalities beyond video.
Feature Comparison
Now let‘s do a detailed feature by feature comparison to understand their capabilities better.
Hardware Capabilities
When it comes to maximum supported resolutions, smart TVs edge out Roku. High end smart TVs like the LG OLED CX series support up to 4K resolution at 120Hz refresh rates. Some 8K models have started rolling out as well. Roku‘s devices currently max out at 4K 60Hz.
Both platforms support HDR formats like Dolby Vision and HDR10+ for improved contrast and colors. High end 2020 models typically support 120Hz refresh rates. If your priority is having cutting edge display capabilities like 8K resolution or 144Hz gaming, smart TVs pull ahead. For most households though, Roku‘s 4K 60Hz is more than enough.
On the audio side, several smart TV series and all modern Roku devices come with Dolby Atmos decoding built-in. This allows you to experience immersive audio from content that carries an Atmos track. Soundbars that support Dolby Atmos can further enhance your experience.
Apps and Content
When it comes to apps and content libraries, Roku still has a significant lead over individual smart TV platforms. Roku phones claim over 5,000 channels while Samsung‘s Tizen OS has around 500 apps. I have found niche apps and channels available easily on Roku that are missing from my LG TV‘s webOS platform.
Of course, both cover all the major services like Netflix, Prime Video, Disney+ Hotstar, YouTube etc. But Roku‘s singular focus on streaming gives it an edge in aggregating channels and providers. Smart TVs look to offer an all round experience through their own ecosystems and partnerships. Application variety takes a back seat.
Ease of Use
I find Roku provides a simpler, easy to navigate interface compared to smart TV platforms. Settings are easy to find with fewer nested menu levels. The home screen simply surfaces the main streaming apps rather than try to show off the TV‘s features. The apps-only focus of their software delivers a smooth experience geared towards streaming.
That said, smart TV interfaces have improved by leaps and bounds from early implementations. LG and Sony smart TV OS feel responsive and easy to use. Budget smart TV software still has some way to go. Get a mid to high end smart TV, and you will be fairly satisfied.
But modern Roku devices set the benchmark for simple and intuitive software that just works. The mobile app is excellent too for searching and controlling your Roku streamer.
Smart Home Connectivity
Most smart TV platforms integrate well with Google Assistant and Amazon‘s Alexa for hands-free voice commands. High end sets connect with smart home hubs like Google Home and Alexa. Entry level smart TVs drop such integrations.
Roku devices also work with both major assistants. And they go further by offering private listening on the mobile app as well as their own Roku mobile app that fully replaces remote control functionality. Ro
Voice Assistants
Smart TVs and Roku have evenly matched voice assistant capabilities. Top end models in both categories work with Google Assistant and Amazon Alexa. You can issue voice commands to launch apps, search for content etc. Most mid-range and high end models come with microphones built into their remotes so that you can speak commands without any additional hardware.
Roku does have one advantage in this department. Their highest-end Ultra device comes with a lost remote finder that makes the remote beep when prompted. So if you‘re prone to misplacing remotes, that‘s a handy feature. The Roku mobile app can fully replace the remote as well.
Audio Capabilities
When it comes to audio capabilities, both Rokus and smart TV platforms are evenly matched. Most mid-range to high end models support Dolby Atmos for immersive sound. Many also provide DTS decoding support. Enthusiasts may favor Roku devices that let you connect advanced soundbars and receivers to handle all audio decoding. But for most households, built-in Dolby Atmos is more than enough.
Pricing
Roku devices start at just $25 for the Roku Express HD model. The fully loaded Ultra will set you back around $100. So it is an affordable way to add smart streaming capabilities to any TV. Being an extra device, it does add a few cables. But compact streamers like the Roku Streaming Stick disappear neatly behind wall mounted TVs.
Smart TVs have a huge range based on display specs and sizes. Entry 32 inch HD models start around $150 while high-end 4K OLED TV cost over $2000. Comparing prices isn‘t apples to apples. A $500 4K smart TV provides better value than say a $200 HD TV plus $100 Roku Streaming Stick.
Pros and Cons Comparison
| Smart TVs | Roku |
|---|---|
| Pros | -Beautiful displays with top notch HDR support -Easy access to streaming apps -Intuitive smart TV interfaces -Works with smart home ecosystems |
| Cons | -App selection lags Roku -Some platforms have ads in menus |
Recommendations Based on User Profiles
Now that we‘ve compared features in detail, let me offer some recommendations based on common user profiles and preferences.
Casual streamers who mainly use Netflix and Prime Video are well served by even budget smart TVs. Go for TCL or Vizio if you want value. Step up to LG, Sony or Samsung for better performance.
Enthusiasts who want the widest app selection and best interface should get a Roku Streaming Player or Roku TV. The huge channel collection and customizable experience outweigh smart TV limitations for diehard streamers.
Gamers and sports fans who care about refresh rates and VRR support should get a higher end smart TV from LG, Sony or Samsung rather than be limited by Roku‘s 60Hz barrier. Display performance matters most here.
Cord cutters looking for the widest variety of content and live TV channels can benefit from Roku‘s wider app support. If you are moving beyond the streaming services, Roku still aggregates way more niche content.
Smart home lovers get decent integration with either. Still I recommend using a dedicated hub like Alexa Echo or Google Home for full smart home centralization and automation. Both Roku and Smart TVs work well with these hubs.
I hope this detailed feature comparison helps you choose the right streaming platform – Roku vs Smart TV – for your preferences and priorities!
