As a long-time technology analyst and audio enthusiast, readers often ask me for advice on the latest gadgets like portable Bluetooth speakers. The JBL Charge series holds prestige in this category for its bold signature sound and rugged durability. However, before rushing to purchase the new Charge 5, ponder these five disadvantages I‘ve observed that may influence your decision.
A Quick Primer on JBL‘s Charge Lineup
First, some quick history on the Charge speaker lineage. JBL debuted the original Charge back in 2013 as a compact cylindar-shaped Bluetooth speaker with thunderous sound, integrated power bank, and unique fabric coating.
This formula clearly resonated with consumers because new Charge iterations have continued releasing every 2-3 years since, retaining the same core DNA while adding upgrades like improved battery life, waterproofing, and Bluetooth connectivity.
The latest entrant is the Charge 5 launched in 2021, now in its second year on the market. Let‘s examine how this fifth-generation model stands up across a few key criteria.
Reason 1: Steep Pricing at $180
While JBL dominates the portable speaker arena, the Charge 5 is not the most budget-friendly option, carrying a list price of $179.95.
That positions it closer to a premium-tier speaker despite JBL framing it for more mass-market appeal. For context, here‘s how the Charge 5‘s pricing compares to the competition and previous Charge generations:
| Speaker Model | Price |
|---|---|
| JBL Charge 5 | $179 |
| JBL Charge 4 | $149 |
| JBL Charge 3 | $129 |
| Bose Soundlink Micro | $99 |
| Anker Soundcore 3 | $79 |
| Tribit Stormbox Micro | $47 |
As you can see, within the broader portable speaker arena, sub-$100 options are far more common. The elder Charge 3 and Charge 4 deliver extremely similar performance and features for $20-50 less.
Before you spend nearly $200 on the latest and greatest, ask yourself how much value you place on modest improvements that may only be incremental upgrades over prior generations.
Reason 2: Large, Heavy Form Factor
While "portable" falls within its name, the Charge 5 is bulkier than many buyers may expect for an on-the-go speaker measuring 8.7 x 3.7 x 3.7 inches and weighing 2.1 lbs.
By comparison, the recently released JBL Clip 4 stands at just 3.7 x 2.5 x 1.3 inches while barely tipping the scales at 0.5 lbs – fitting easily in pockets and bags.
Now the Charge 5‘s scale allows it to deliver impressive bass and volume. But if you plan on attaching it to backpacks for hikes or tossing it in carry-ons, more compact options like the Bose Soundlink Micro or JBL Flip 6 could prove easier travel companions.
Plan to mostly listen in one spot? The Charge 5‘s size won‘t matter as much. But anticipate carrying it around frequently, and bulkiness becomes a hindrance.
Reason 3: Bass-Heavy Sound Signatue
With the Charge 5, JBL continues accentuating low-end bass response above all else – upholding a sonic tradition across the Charge lineage.
This bass boost lends an instantly gripping, vibrant quality to genres like hip hop, EDM, and rock that thrive on those thumping low frequencies.
However, the bias towards bass could also overshadow vocals and mid-range clarity for styles like folk, classical, podcasts, and audiobooks. The sound profile skews too overpowering without enough balance and articulation.
While equalizer adjustments could potentially tune and tame the abundance of bass, the Charge 5 lacks any sort of EQ customization. You‘re locked into JBL‘s stock signature prioritizing bold bass at the expense of mids/highs.
Reason 4: No Audio Customization Whatsover
Beyond powering the speaker on and off, JBL provides zero audio tweaking options to adapt the listening experience to your preferences.
Many rival speakers in this price range from Sony, Denon, and Anker, among others, bake in customizable EQs or at least quick preset modes like Bass Boost and Treble Boost.
But the Charge 5 omits any sort of sound modification capability. For casual listeners, this shouldn‘t pose much issue. Set it and forget it.
However, lacking any EQ flexibility could disappoint discerning audiophiles seeking more granular audio adjustments. Expect bass and treble levels fixed at JBL‘s predetermined levels without any wiggle room.
Reason 5: The Charge 6 Could Launch Soon
Checking the historical release records, JBL has delivered:
- Charge 1: 2013
- Charge 2: 2014
- Charge 3: 2016
- Charge 4: 2018
- Charge 5: 2021
Notice the pattern of refreshing the Charge every 2 to 3 years on average?
Given the Charge 5 landed two years ago in 2021, I anticipate the Charge 6 coming as early as late 2023.
You can already expect the next iteration to pack upgrades like extended 30+ battery life thanks to larger cell capacity, Bluetooth 5.3 for longer range and fidelity, durable scratch-resistant finish, and potentially even smart features through Google Assistant or Amazon Alexa integration.
If you don‘t need a rugged speaker urgently, waiting to see what the Charge 6 delivers could reward your patience!
The Bottom Line
I don‘t aim to completely discourage buying the Charge 5 – only highlight drawbacks worth your consideration from pricing to sonic limitations. As with any electronics purchase, carefully reflect on the pros and cons against your intended uses.
For some, the Charge 5 strikes the right cord with its familiar imposing sound, ruggedness, and 20-hour endurance. It still brings ample strengths to the table.
But also give alternatives like the Flip 6, Boombox 3 or waiting for the next Charge refresh some thought before pulling the trigger! Hopefully examining the current generation‘s disadvantages assists your decision-making process to determine the best audio solution for your needs.
Let me know in the comments if you have any other questions!