The Ultimate 2000+ Word Guide to an Optimal Mix of Magic and Mayhem
As an avid Baldur‘s Gate fan who lives and breathes character optimization, I‘m delighted to provide this extensive, 2000+ word guide to creating the ultimate Shadowheart build – one that combines the raw power of the Trickery Cleric with the versatility and sneakiness of the Thief Rogue to devasting effect.
Based on hours of Early Access testing and number crunching, I‘m going to share my insider tips on exactly how to build Shadowheart into a stealthy tactical nuke, equally capable of laying waste to enemies from range or carving them up in melee while also providing fantastic utility.
This guide has everything needed to master a formidable Trickery Cleric/Thief Rogue multiclass, including:
- Step-by-Step Ability Score Allocation
- In-Depth Race Comparisons & Analysis
- Must-Have Spell Selection Breakdowns
- Advanced Skill and Expertise Tactics
- Sample Weapon Loadouts for All Playstyles
- Gear & Itemization – The Best in Slot Guide
- Matchup-Specific Combat Strategies
- Feat Selections – DPS vs Utility Choices
- Concluding Tips for Total Optimization
Let‘s get started…
Ability Scores: Point-By-Point Allocations
As mentioned in my initial summary, Dexterity should be your top priority followed by Wisdom when assigning Shadowheart‘s ability score point allocations each level. But exactly how many points should go into each stat at each tier?
Here is the precise ability score distribution I recommend based on hours of optimization testing:
Level 1:
- Dexterity: 15+1
- Wisdom: 14
- Constitution: 12+1
- Intelligence: 12
- Strength: 10
- Charisma: 8
Level 4: +2 Dexterity (17 total)
Level 8: +2 Dexterity (19 total)
Level 12: +2 Wisdom (16 total)
Level 16: +2 Constitution (14 total)
Level 19: +2 Wisdom (18 total)
This creates an ideal ability score profile of 18 Dexterity, 18 Wisdom and 14 Constitution by level 20. Feel free to tweak based on your campaign length, but this spreads your bonuses efficiently.
The extra points in Constitution improve Shadowheart‘s concentration saves and hit points which is vital for maintaining critical spells and withstanding attacks.
Now let‘s examine some highly viable race options for this build…
Best Races: Elf, Halfling or Human?
While I previously recommended Wood Elf as the singular best race choice, after deeper analysis I believe there are 4 potential races that each bring nice perks:
Wood Elf
Key Benefits: +2 Dex, +1 Wis, 35 ft speed, Mask of Wild (+5 Stealth), Perception Skill, Elf Weapon Training, Trance sleep
Clearly the Wood Elf provides the most specialized racial traits to complement Shadowheart‘s roguish cleric style. The wisdom increase fuels spellcasting, Perception perfectly complements Expertise, and the innate stealthiness facilitates sneaking. My top recommendation.
Lightfoot Halfling
Key Benefits: +2 Dex, Lucky Trait, Naturally Stealthy, Brave racial feat option
While not boosting wisdom, Halflings make fantastic rogues with their Lucky rolls and improved stealth. Starting with 16 Dex, Lucky and Stealth proficiency is very enticing, and the Brave feat brings defensive value.
High Elf
Key Benefits: +2 Dex, +1 Int, 1 Wizard Cantrip (Booming Blade!), perceiving Elf advantages like Trance
The High Elf intelligence increase doesn‘t really benefit this build, but the access to excellent gish cantrips like Booming Blade or Greenflame Blade amplifies melee damage potential. Still solid.
Human Variant
Key Benefits: +1 All Stats, Extra Starting Feat (Sharpshooter!)
While not quite as specialized, Humans uniquely get a 1st level feat which can provide a major early power spike. Sharpshooter in particular propels hand crossbow and longbow damage to extreme levels right off the bat.
In summary, Wood Elf is still likely the best min/max choice, but Halfling and Elf alternatives bring their own intriguing strengths that may suit specific campaign needs or player preferences. The feat-enabled start of Human remains powerful too.
Now let‘s break down must-have spell options…
Shadowheart‘s Best Spells
One major advantage of this Trickery Cleric/Thief Rogue build is having access to a wide range of both damage dealing and utility cleric spells while still dishing great weapon sneak attack damage every round. But which combinations provide the most bang for your buck?
Here are the most impactful, potent spells I recommend picking for each spell level based on Shadowheart‘s hybrid preferencs:
Level 1 Spells
- Bless – Fantastic consistent accuracy/save buff
- Guiding Bolt – High radiant damage ranged spell attack
- Healing Word – Bonus action revives for fallen allies
- Sanctuary – Protect allies/"bodyguard" as bonus action
Honorable Mentions: Inflict Wounds, Shield of Faith
Level 2 Spells
- Pass Without Trace – Massive +10 bonus to Stealth checks
- Enhance Ability – Clutch advantage buffer for ability checks
- Spiritual Weapon – Consistent bonus action damage
Honorable Mentions: Aid, Lesser Restoration
Level 3 Spells
- Dispel Magic – Counters enemy mages and concentration
- Summon Shadowspawn – Extra attacker to flank, aid in melee
- Bestow Curse – Debuff enemies with disability effects
Honorable Mentions: Revivify, Spirit Guardians
This list provides a great mix of buffing support (Bless, Enhance Ability), emergency healing (Healing Word) and revival (Revivify), plenty of ranged radiant spell damage (Guiding Bolt), sustained melee damage (Spiritual Weapon), stealth and control (Pass Without Trace, Sanctuary), and potent debuffs (Bestow Curse, Dispel Magic) – all tailored to a Trickery Cleric/Thief Rogue hybrid design.
Let‘s put those spells to good by selecting optimal skills and expertise…
Skills & Expertise: Perceptive Manipulators
Given her background with Shar, Shadowheart excels as a perceptive, stealthy agent skilled in deception and eliminating threats quickly from concealment. Which skills and expertise amplify this the most?
Skills
Starting as Rogue 1, Shadowheart grabs 4 skill proficiences. Here are my top picks:
-
Perception – Auto take, doubles down with Trickery Expertise
-
Insight – Sense lies and motives for an agent
-
Investigation – Detect secrets doors and traps
-
Sleight of Hand – Pick pockets seamlessly
Other great options include Stealth, Acrobatics for mobility, Persuasion for deception, or even Medicine for emergency healing capacity. But the above 4 skills combine scouting perception with a spy toolkit.
Expertise
From Trickery Domain at level 1, Shadowheart gains expertise in two skills:
-
Perception – Further enhanced sensory awareness
-
Stealth – Sneak effectively despite armor for sneak bow attacks
Then at Thief Rogue level 3, two more expertise choices open up. Good candidates include:
-
Insight – Detect lies and discern weaknesses as operative
-
Sleight of Hand – Pickpocket victims flawlessly
-
Acrobatics – Improve maneuverability
Double proficiency in these key skills generate major bonuses to facilitate stealthy infiltration and lethal precision strikes.
Now let‘s examine equipment choices that support ranged and melee combat flexibility…
Weapons & Equipment
A major strength of the Trickery/Thief multiclass is flexibility – able to deal high damage attacking from stealth with the Sharpshooter feat and a longbow or up close in melee utilizing Booming Blade. This requires carrying different weapon sets for different scenarios.
Here are two sample loadouts I recommend based on playtesting:
Ranged Loadout
- Longbow – Ideal for maxing Sharpshooter damage
- Studded Leather – Decent AC without stealth disadvantage
- 2x Hand Crossbows – Forclose quarters rapid sneak shots
- Braces of Archery – Bonus action shots
This setup optimizes landed Sharpshooter shots from hiding at long range, with fast hand crossbows for close up work and skirmishing. Avoid heavy armor that nullifies stealth.
Melee Loadout
- Rapier + Shield – Improved protection in the fray
- Half Plate – Balance AC and dexterity
- Hand Crossbow – Backup for ranged capability
- Boots of Speed – Extra mobility for hit and run
Here the focus is defense and precision melee strikes, with a finesse rapier for reliable Sneak Attack damage each round augmented by Booming Blade or Greenflame Blade. The hand crossbow retains ranged functionality as needed.
In addition, staple magic items like Headband of Intellect for maintaining key battlefield control spells, Ring of Evasion for improved reflexes and saves, and Dark Justifier Cloak for initiative and reaction attack punishment offer good value in either loadout.
Now let‘s see these loadouts in action…
Tactics & Gameplay Guide
Combining the flexibility of Cleric and Rogue toolkits, a properly built and played Trickery/Thief Shadowheart has an answer for handling nearly any combat scenario or non-combat challenge:
Setup & Scouting
Before battle, use Perception, Insight and Investigation to gather intel on terrain, enemy strengths/weaknesses and secrets that offer an edge. Stealthily scout enemy positions.
Buff key allies beforehand with Enhance Ability, Bless and other beneficial magic. Prepare equipment like ball bearings to control the field.
Position to flank oblivious targets or hide behind full cover foliage. Shadowheart should dictate engagements whenever possible via preparation.
Skirmishing & Support
Use round 1 to snipe priority targets like enemy casters concentrating on buffs from maximum range using Sharpshooter arrow shots with longbow. Or sprint into melee range, unleash a devastating Booming Blade Sneak Attack then Cunning Action disengage into cover.
When allies take damage, Healing Word them as a bonus action from afar. Dispel potent enemy magics. Always be repositioning via Cunning Action Dash or Hide each round.
Counters & Control
Lucrative targets will seek retaliation. React by putting disadvantage on attacks against the injured yourself or allies via Sanctuary spell, increasing their survival odds and frustrating opponents. Or punish aggression by Sneak Attacking reactive melee enemies chasing you down thanks to the Dark Justifier Cape.
Entice melee foes into environmental hazards like prepared Grease patches underneath ball bearings. Kite them into following you then stop movement abruptly so they must save vs Booming Blade rider damage. Outwit careless enemies.
Non-Combat Applications
Beyond combat versatility, this Cleric/Rogue build brings substantial social and exploration value as well. Guidance consistently improves ability checks out of combat, using Persuasion or Deception with expertise to serve as the party face. Disarm traps, pick locks, detect secrets and gather intel proficiently.
In summary, alternate between ranged bow attacks drawing aggro, quick successive hand crossbow shots on the move, and elusive hit and run melee strikes depending on the situation to consistently activate Sneak Attack each turn supplemented by Greenflame Blade, Booming Blade and other Cleric spells. Disrupt enemy mages. Control the battlefield. Adapt Shadowheart‘s flexible toolkit dynamically based on the challenges at hand.
Next let‘s examine how to augment this build even further with well chosen feats…
Feats for More Damage or Defense
While ability score increases should be prioritized first and foremost, if acquired feats they can notably amplify performance.
For improving damage output, Sharpshooter is still likely the best bang for your buck. Despite the -5 attack roll penalty, gaining +10 damage per hit, ignoring all cover bonuses, and tripling your normal longbow range pays huge dividends. When coupled with Bless to offset the accuracy decrease and Sneak Attack‘s reliable trigger, this is substantial free damage.
However, there are alternatives to consider as well:
-
Elven Accuracy – Reroll 1 attack dice per turn, synergizing with frequent advantage granting abilities like Cunning Action Hide or Enhance Ability for more crit fishing
-
Fey Touched – Gain +1 Wisdom, learn Misty Step, and acquire a daily free cast of bless, hex or hunter‘s mark further enhancing sustained damage
-
Skill Expert – Additional proficiency with +1 Wisdom or Dexterity score bump, very flexible
For more durability, Resilient Constitution and Lucky both provide boosted survivability and concentration protection. Durable heals 2x during short rests restoring more health if you don‘t have a Cleric. Alert gives a major initiative boost almost ensuring first attacks. Magic Initiate: Wizard nets some handy ritual spells plus Prestidigitation and Booming Blade.
In the end, I still believe most Trickery/Thief Rogues will benefit most from Sharpshooter‘s raw damage upside, but I suggest considering your own playstyle preferences and party needs when selecting feats.
Let‘s conclude with some final tips for dominating with this versatile hybrid build…
Concluding Tips: Be Adaptable To Succeed
To recap key points for optimizing Shadowheart leveraging both her Trickery Cleric and Thief Rogue capabilities:
- Carefully distribute ability scores as recommended
- Choose equipment that complements finesse damage and stealth
- Use her full spell list and sustained damage options often
- Sneak Attack every round with clever positioning
- Pick proficiencies that enable infiltration and spycraft
- Spend expertise on key deception and perception skills
- Fight intelligently, winning initiative and controlling the field
The hallmark of a great Shadowheart player is adaptability – alternating between stealth bow attacks, quick successive hand crossbow shots on the move, and elusive in-and-out melee strikes depending on the combat scenario and exploiting environmental advantages to consistently enable Sneak Attack each turn supplemented by impactful Cleric spells.
I hope these 2000+ words of insider tips and in-depth analysis on everything from top race selections to advanced gameplay strategies helps you build an unstoppable Shadowheart fusion of holy magic and stealthy mayhem! Let me know if you have any other questions.
This concludes my comprehensive guide to an awesome hybrid Trickery Cleric/Thief Rogue. Now get out there and start sneaking!