Skip to content

RAM vs ROM: An In-Depth Comparison

What is RAM?

RAM stands for Random Access Memory. It is a form of volatile computer memory that temporarily stores data and machine code currently being accessed by the CPU. The term "random access" refers to the ability to access any piece of data directly, without needing to iterate through all the preceding data first.

Some key characteristics of RAM include:

  • Volatile – Contents are lost when power is removed
  • Fast read/write speeds – Enables quick access by the CPU
  • Silicon-based integrated circuits
  • Various technologies over the years: SRAM, DRAM, SDRAM, DDR SDRAM etc
  • Upgradeable – Most systems have spare RAM slots to add more memory

RAM gives computers an extremely fast "workspace" to operate in. Without enough RAM, even the fastest processors would grind to a halt, constantly waiting for data to be loaded from the comparatively slow hard drives.

What is ROM?

ROM stands for Read-Only Memory. It is a form of non-volatile storage used in computers and other electronic devices to store firmware, machine code and data that needs to persist when power is removed. "Read-only" means the data cannot be modified or re-written by the end user.

Some key characteristics of ROM include:

  • Non-volatile – Contents remain even without power
  • Much slower than RAM
  • Stores critical boot data, e.g. BIOS firmware
  • Various technologies: PROM, EPROM, EEPROM etc
  • Rarely upgraded or modified once written

ROM contains vital startup instructions for devices – when switched on, the device CPU will access the ROM to load the necessary code into RAM before proceeding to load the operating system.

A Brief History

RAM and ROM have been integral to computing almost since the first real commercial computers emerged in the 1950s.

Early vacuum tube computers like the Manchester Baby (1948) initially relied on mercury delay line memory – a series of tubes filled with mercury to store acoustic pulses. This was volatile memory analogous to modern RAM. Early computers also used read-only memory in the form of punched paper tape and punched cards.

The invention of magnetic core memory in the early 1950s – an arrangement of tiny ferrite toroids able to store bits magnetically – paved the way for solid state RAM. IBM‘s first commercial computer in 1953 used magnetic cores for memory.

During the 1960s, metal–oxide–semiconductor (MOS) large scale integration led to the first silicon based RAM – initially static RAM using flip flop circuits able to retain data as long as power was applied. Dynamic RAM storing data in capacitors soon followed – refreshed thousands of times per second before discharging.

Early read-only memory took forms like diode matrices or masks applied to memory arrays during manufacture. Erasable programmable read-only memory (EPROM) using floating-gate MOSFETs emerged in 1971 – allowing ROM to be erased via UV light exposure. Electrically erasable PROM (EEPROM) followed – erasable byte-wise using electric signals.

Today, RAM and ROM remain essential – with ever denser integration and new technologies like resistive RAM and 3D XPoint aiming to replace aging incumbents.

Types of RAM

There are two main types of random access memory in common usage:

Static RAM (SRAM)

SRAM uses a matrix of latches – bistable flip-flop circuits – to store data bits. So long as power is supplied, the latches maintain their state indefinitely – so SRAM does not need to be refreshed like DRAM.

However, each memory cell requires several transistors. So SRAM densities are much lower than DRAM – making it more expensive. SRAM is used primarily for CPU caches and other performance critical functions where speed is paramount.

Dynamic RAM (DRAM)

DRAM stores data in an array grid of tiny capacitors – essentially microscopic versions of normal capacitors made from silicon rather than plastic/metal. These must be continually refreshed as the charge leaks away over time.

Because they only need a single transistor+capacitor per bit, DRAM chips can reach much higher densities than SRAM – making DRAM cheaper and more suitable for use as main system memory.

As well as simple DRAM, there are many variants including synchronous (SDRAM), double data rate (DDR SDRAM), and graphics variants like GDDR5. These offer various speed and performance enhancements.

Types of ROM

There are three main types of read-only memory in common usage:

Masked ROM

The very earliest type of ROM – a mask is used during manufacture to permanently enable/disable particular array rows/columns corresponding to 1/0 bits. No further changes possible. Often used for large production runs when code will never change.

Programmable ROM (PROM)

An array grid which can be written to once only via higher voltage – becomes permanently enabled/disabled according to written data. Allows customization for each device.

Erasable Programmable ROM (EPROM)

Similar grid array as PROM but data can be erased afterwards – originally via exposure to strong UV light. Allows programs/data to be updated. Electrical erasable PROM (EEPROM) later allowed electrical erase/reprogram on a byte level.

Modern flash memory successors like SD cards and SSDs are derived from early EEPROM tech.

RAM vs ROM Comparison

RAM ROM
Volatility Volatile – contents lost without power Non-volatile – contents persist without power
Speed Much faster read/writes – often 10-100x faster than ROM Generally quite slow relative to RAM
Usage Temporary workspace for currently running apps/OS Permanent storage of firmware & startup code
Upgradability Often user upgradeable by adding more modules Rarely upgraded or modified after initial write

In essence:

  • RAM is optimized for speed and volatility – it gives your programs a lightning fast workspace thats wiped clean when powered off.

  • ROM is optimized for density and persistence – it packs in your devices starter code that never needs changing.

Importance of Each Technology

Both RAM and ROM play vital and complementary roles within any computing device:

Why RAM Matters

Without sufficient RAM, modern multi-tasking computers would choke. RAM powers everything you actively do on a computer – every application and process loads required data and code into RAM where the CPU can access it at full speed.

When RAM fills up, the operating system starts swapping less used data out to the hard disk – introducing huge latency penalties every time that data needs accessing again. Upgrading RAM is one of the most effective ways to speed up an aging computer.

The more RAM, the more applications can run simultaneously without slowdowns. Higher RAM capacity also future proofs devices – allowing more powerful software to run in coming years.

Why ROM Matters

ROM contains the low level machine code sequences needed to start a device up – initializing hardware like the CPU and loading critical code like the BIOS or operating system kernel into RAM ready for execution.

Without ROM, you‘d have an endless chicken and egg situation – the OS is required to access the hard disk, but you need some initial code running to load the OS in the first place. ROM breaks that cycle by providing essential code that always runs first when a device powers on.

By being non-volatile, important firmware and sequences are also safeguarded if devices lose power or are turned off. The same startup routines will execute flawlessly next time without relying on an unstable storage medium like RAM.

Common Misconceptions

There are some common misconceptions regarding the difference between RAM and ROM:

ROM is Superior to RAM

Some assume that non-volatile ROM must be intrinsically better than volatile RAM – after all, won‘t you lose all your data if power is interrupted on RAM?

This representation ignores their different purposes however – RAM enables computers to operate at incredible speeds by giving constant near instant access to currently used data. The volatility trade off is worth it given modern computers rarely unexpectedly "forget".

Attempting to replace RAM with ROM would result in computers thousands of times slower. Hard disks would also wear out nearly instantly from the constant writing as temporary data swapped out from slower ROM – reducing overall reliability.

BIOS is Stored in RAM

Some believe the BIOS firmware itself loads into RAM during the boot process – confusing the loading of data from ROM with a transfer into RAM.

In reality, the BIOS code remains permanently stored in ROM. On startup, it is executed directly from there to initialize hardware and load further runtime programs like OS kernels into RAM ready for launching.

So while a machine is running, the original BIOS instructions remain safely ensconced in their ROM home, ready to be accessed next bootup!

ROM is Disk Storage

Some incorrectly assume ROM simply refers to normal hard disks or SSDs – after all, disks retain data without power and are non volatile.

However disks are categorically different – allowing arbitrary reading and writing unlike the largely fixed ROM. Disks also contain secondary storage of programs and user data rather than the core firmware critical for boot processes before disks can even be accessed.

So while disks and ROM both offer non-volatile storage, they serve entirely distinct roles.

Real World Usage Examples

To help cement the difference between RAM and ROM, here are some real-world examples:

Gaming Consoles

Gaming consoles like the Playstation 5 contain both RAM and ROM chips on their main boards:

  • RAM – 16GB GDDR6 memory from Micron allows ultra fast access for graphics rendering and game asset loading. More RAM allows larger, more detailed game worlds.

  • ROM – A small flash memory chip stores the PlayStation firmware – low level code to initialize the AMD CPU and peripherals on start up ready to launch the OS. Persists between power cycles.

If the RAM fails, games crash or freeze as assets can‘t load. If the ROM fails, the console won‘t boot at all.

Phones/Tablets

Mobile devices also leverage both RAM and ROM:

  • RAM – Flagship phones now contain 8GB+ RAM to maintain multiple apps in memory. Allows faster switching between apps. Upgraded yearly.

  • ROM – Internal flash storage contains the Android/iOS system images to boot up (a form of mask ROM) – persists across recharges. Rarely modified.

Insufficient RAM results in constant app reloading as inactive ones are purged from memory. Failure of the system ROM chip would brick the device entirely unless recovered via external programming.

Embedded Devices

ROM is critical in tiny embedded devices like smart sensors:

  • RAM – A modest amount (e.g. 20KB SRAM) holds temporary sensor readings for processing/transmission. May lose recent readings if power fails.

  • ROM – Code for basic functions like initializing I/O, sampling sensors etc rarely changes. Stored permanently in ROM or masked flash so device can always function on boot up even with corruted RAM after a crash. Upgrades rare once working.

The ROM provides the permanent DNA ensuring the device will come back to life when power restored – RAM simply holds transient runtime data used during normal operation.

The Future of RAM and ROM

New memory technologies are emerging which aim to replace aging incumbents. RAM and ROM have remained conceptually similar for over half a century – but chips can only shrink so far. Modern devices require storage and memory at massive scale – driving intense research into next generation memory:

Post RAM?

various technologies aim to fill the increasing gap between RAM speed and storage density – allowing massively bigger and/or faster memory:

  • 3D XPoint – 1000x faster than flash with similar density. Massively paralleled phase change cells. Aims to slot between RAM and SSDs.

  • Z-RAM – Uses floating gate flash cells in two speed tiers – DRAM speed Z-RAM cached to larger but slower NVRAM. Persists like disks when powered off.

  • Resistive RAM – Cells change resistance rather than charge to signify 1 or 0. Enables much simpler, denser arrays stacked in 3D. ~10x denser than DRAM.

If succesful, super fast non-volatile RAM could remove temporary vs permanent memory divide completely – everything instant and persistent by default. Virtual machines suspending to disk would become obsolete – they would simply persist automatically wherever powered off last!

Post ROM?

Emerging persistent memory technologies also challenge traditional ROM:

  • ReRAM – Resistive RAM competing with flash for non volatile storage. No mechanical parts, very scalable.

  • PCM – Phase change materials toggled between amorphous and crystalline states. Multilevel cells possible for high densities.

  • STT-MRAM – Magnetic tunnel junctions toggled via spin transfer torque. Near infinite write endurance.

If matured, such technologies could come to dominate firmware/code storage – replacing aging flash and mask ROM with a sea of dense, non volatile universal memory combining the best of today‘s RAM and ROM.

The Fundamental Divide

Yet despite shifting underlying hardware, the fundamental distinction between speed oriented volatile memory and non-volatile storage is likely to remain. The economics and physics simply favor such a divide rather than attempting to create mythical "universal memory" combining both perfect speed and retention.

Like the hard disk vs RAM divide today, super fast non volatile RAM could find itself filling precisely the same quick access role as today‘s DRAM – while denser persistent storage emerges below it in the memory hierarchy for more permanent code and data.

The labels may change, but the speed vs persistence divide seems destined to remain as computing demand continues growing exponentially year after year!

Tags: