As an EV enthusiast and technology analyst, few things excite me more than the acceleration of the electric luxury performance segment. Tesla undoubtedly lit this fuse beginning over a decade ago. But the Swedish upstart Polestar has burst onto the scene of late with compelling alternatives for the eco-conscious driving purist.
You’re likely cross-shopping the tight Polestar 2 Performance fastback and the Tesla Model 3 Performance sedan because of their blend of sustainability and unrelenting torque. Both vehicles promise carbon-friendly transportation without sacrificing on-ramp g-forces. But beyond the internet chatter, how do these flagship electric sport sedans compare under the scrutiny of an experienced gearhead? Let’s analyze this rivalry across over two dozen criteria to determine a definitive victor.
An Origin Story: Polestar vs Tesla
Polestar began independent tuning and racing Volvos in 1996 before being acquired outright by the Swedish automaker in 2015. Sensing an opportunity to electrify their performance portfolio as regulatory pressures mounted, parent company Geely Holding relaunched Polestar as a standalone electric vehicle brand just 4 years ago. Their initial Polestar 1 plug-in hybrid grand tourer set the stage for the all-electric Polestar 2 midsize 4-door sedan first delivered to customers in 2020.
Meanwhile Tesla Motors incorporated under the visionary leadership of Martin Eberhard and Marc Tarpenning in 2003. The scrappy startup set out to prove electric propulsion could not just keep up but surpass internal combustion. Bankrolled by Elon Musk starting in 2004, Tesla shocked the world with the torching Roadster sportscar unveiled 2006. The company went public in 2010 and has since doubled down on ambition, promising full self-driving capability and near-lightspeed charging for millions.
So while Polestar leans on decades of Volvo engineering credibility in Scandinavian restraint, Tesla plays the role of Silicon Valley disrupter. This leads to diverging philosophies in solving for high performance electric mobility.
By the Numbers: Specs and Capabilities
Digging into the details reveals Tesla’s specification advantage stemming from years perfecting skateboard-style platforms and obsessively iterating battery density. Have a glance at metrics like horsepower, 0-60 acceleration, charging speed and range side-by-side:
| Specification | Polestar 2 Performance | Tesla Model 3 Performance |
|---|---|---|
| Max Power Output | 300 kW (408 hp) | 283 kW (380 hp) |
| 0-60 mph Acceleration | 4.2 seconds | 3.1 seconds |
| Top Speed | 127 mph | 162 mph |
| Max Charging Speed | 150 kW | 250 kW |
| EPA Range | 249 mi | 315 mi |
Clearly the Tesla enjoys measurable leads critical for enthusiastic driving. But Polestar keeps it closer than any rival has managed to date, while saving buyers over $4,500 upfront based on current MSRPs.
Now let’s scrutinize what lies underneath these machines to explain the performance deltas.
Technical Deep Dive: Motors, Batteries and More
Both automakers have invested in proprietary electric propulsion and energy storage innovations as their secret sauce. Here’s what gives each EV an edge or shortcoming on drivetrain duty.
Motors
- The Polestar 2 Performance sports front and rear axle permanent magnet synchronous AC motors for 300kW and all-wheel traction.
- Tesla Model 3 Performance rear motor offers higher 283 kW max power despite fewer total drive units.
Advantage: Tesla for greater power density
Battery Energy Storage
- 78 kWh lithium ion battery pack in Polestar 2 weighing 473 kg rated for 249 mi range.
- 82.5 kWh Tesla battery option provides 315 mi max range. Newer 4680 cell structural architecture cut mass.
Advantage: Tesla for capacity, chemistry and charge curve
Thermal Management
- Polestar utilizes standard liquid cooling and heating to preserve battery and motor efficiency.
- Tesla integrates cutting-edge heat pump for battery temperature regulation, reducing drain.
Advantage: Tesla for sophisticated thermal optimization
Charging
- Polestar 2 accepts 150 kW public DC fast charging for 80% replenish in under 40 minutes.
- Tesla Supercharger peak charging exceeds 250 kW, enabling under 25 minute 15-80% charge time.
Advantage: Tesla for proprietary ultra-rapid infrastructure
Performance Upgrades
- Öhlins 2-way adjustable dampers standard on Polestar improve handling.
- Model 3 offers upgraded torque vectoring and stability control for sharper turn-in and power down exiting corners.
Toss-up depending on preference
Clearly Tesla’s extensive EV drivetrain expertise and charging network investments pay dividends in measurable performance criteria. But Polestar keeps it close while charting its own course on engineering.
Self Driving and Autonomy
Tesla also maintains a yawning lead over Polestar when it comes to automated driving capability thanks to billions invested in custom silicon, sensors and neural network training.
While Polestar 2 incorporates standard advanced driver assistance systems like adaptive cruise control, blind spot warning and lane keep assistance to ease traffic fatigue, Tesla Autopilot enables advanced autonomy via:
- Custom in-house AI processors for parallel neural net computations
- 8 external cameras, 12 ultrasonic sensors and forward radar for 360° vision
- Robust sensor fusion, trajectory planning and vehicle control algorithms
- Over-the-air software update distribution pipeline
- Billions of miles of empirical autopilot driving data logged
No other automaker comes close to Full Self Driving potential promised by Tesla. Polestar finds itself relegated to ADAS features typical across the industry.
Charging Convenience and Trip Planning
Prospective buyers rightly worry about public charging availability limiting electric road trip range anxiety and flexibility relative to gas stations. Tesla again carries the day based on an industry leading fast charging network comprised of:
- Over 40,000 Supercharger Stalls worldwide
- 200-250 kW charging capability at v3 locations
- 1750 global destinations and counting
- Reliable uptime and maintenance
- Seamless route, wait time and amenity visibility via vehicle software
The press may exaggerate occasional Tesla Supercharger congestion on high traffic corridors. But no network matches the scale and trip planning confidence Tesla provides through continued capital investment. Because Polestar relies on a patchwork of incompatible third party DC fast charging stations, road warriors experience more fatigue and frustration planning long distance travel.
Until alternatives approach the accessibility and charging speeds Teslas drivers enjoy from North Carolina to Norway, this remains a huge ownership perk.
Interior Space, Storage and Passenger Room
As 4-door fastback sedans on dedicated EV platforms, both models offer excellent interior volume indexing while maintaining sporty swept profiles. Have a look at passenger and cargo dimensions.
Polestar 2
- 5-seat configuration
- Rear leg room: 35 inches
- Front leg room: 41 inches
- Head room (front/rear): 40/37 inches
- Cargo volume (rear): 14.8 cubic feet
Tesla Model 3
- 5-seat configuration
- Rear leg room: 35 inches
- Front leg room: 42 inches
- Head room (front/rear): 40/37 inches
- Cargo volume: 15 cubic feet
Essentially a wash here, with less than an inch separating most comfort metrics. Both cars swallow rear passengers and gear admirably well relative to traditional internal combustion coupes. Families find flexibility while individuals enjoy the dramatic styling.
Infotainment, Controls and Cabin Features
Polestar strikes out on its own using Google’s Android Automotive operating system, while Tesla pioneered and continues iterating their proprietary in-house software stack across every touchscreen. There are tradeoffs to each approach.
-
Polestar 2 leverages Google Maps, Assistant voice commands and the Play Store
-
Tesla OS looks and feels more modern with integrated apps and controls
-
Polestar offers optional $3,200 audio upgrade by Bowers and Wilkins
-
Tesla provides streaming music and entertainment services
These differences come down to personal preference. Neither system fully catches up to mobile phones in responsiveness or reliability just yet. Expect rapid evolution in coming years.
Style and Customization
Beauty resides in the eye of the beholder, but both these electric sport sedans make a statement while maintaining reasonable practicality. Beyond the badge, here are some differentiation points on personalization:
Exterior Color Options
- Polestar 2: Black, Snow, Magnesium, Thunder, Void, Moon, Midnight
- Tesla Model 3: Solid Black, Midnight Silver Metallic, Deep Blue Metallic, Pearl White Multi-Coat
Wheels
- Polestar 2: 19" 5-Spoke Alloy, 20" 10-Spoke Alloy
- Tesla Model 3: 18” Aero, 19" Sport, 20” Überturbine
Interior Trim
- Polestar 2: Black seats with slate deco panels
- Tesla Model 3: All black interior with carbon fiber decor
Again this comes down to preference on understated themes or independent expression. Both EV interiors impress with sustainability and precision.
Safety Technology and Crash Protection
You’ll rest easy from a passenger protection standpoint choosing either electric vehicle. Both achieve top ratings across the board on the safety front.
Polestar 2
- 5-Star Euro NCAP overall rating
- Driver Assistance Score: 85%
- Safety Assist Score: 86%
- Occupant Protection Score: 91%
Tesla Model 3
- 5-Star Overall NHTSA Rating
- Chance of Injury: 6%
- Chance of Death: 4%
- Superstructure stiffness for impact absorption
With Polestar’s Volvo lineage and Tesla’s engineering obsession, both companies take preventing harm seriously employing science. No wrong choice here.
Service Network and Warranties
Polestar plans over 25 retail showrooms across North America by end of 2023 supplementing dealer service centers in Canada. Tesla’s retail footprint already spans dozens of hub locations supplemented by ranger mobile technicians for at home repairs. Both automakers navigate service challenges growing electric sales with startups Scandanavia and Spark. Time will tell whether either or both achieve Lexus-level satisfaction metrics.
Polestar Warranty
- New car: 4 years/50,000 miles
- Battery: 8 years/100,000 miles
Tesla Warranty
- New car: 4 years/50,000 miles
- Battery/drivetrain: 8 years/100,000-120,000 miles
Essentially equivalent protections accompany both choice EVs. Tesla’s track record suggests below average reliability thus far per Consumer Reports data. Polestar remains too new to gauge long term mechanical defects or electrical gremlins.
Lifetime Total Cost of Ownership
Factoring purchase price, financing rates, insurance costs, lifetime fuel savings, tax incentives and resale value, experts forecast the Polestar 2 and Model 3 lifetime ownership costs as follows:
Polestar 2
- Purchase Price: $57,400 (avg)
- 5 Year Cost: $0.85 per mile
- 75,000 Mile Cost: $66,450
Tesla Model 3 Performance
- Purchase Price: $62,990 (avg)
- 5 Year Cost: $0.78 per mile
- 75,000 Mile Cost: $61,700
Thanks mostly to superior resale value retention, the Tesla also prevails as the cheaper long term ownership proposition despite higher initial purchase price. Savvy buyers crunch these numbers purchasing any vehicle.
Verdict: Tesla Model 3 Performance Still Reigns Supreme
Digging into the details across over 25 different comparison criteria, the Tesla Model 3 Performance retains a clear technical advantage over the plucky Polestar 2 Performance attempting to challenge for the throne of affordable sustainable track star.
I applaud Polestar massively reducing the performance gap by leveraging economies of scale from Volvo’s established automaking infrastructure. And they’ve got the bones of a true Tesla competitor if battery tech and charging infrastructure catch up in coming years. Helping public awareness, the Polestar 2 won several prominent Car of the Year awards since launch overseas.
But benchmarking range, acceleration, charging speed and advanced self-driving software, the Tesla remains peerless having prioritized these capabilities since day one under Elon Musk’s leadership. While Musk and Tesla certainly invite controversy on many fronts, their defining a new era of electrification remains under-appreciated by legacy manufacturers who clung too long to the internal combustion glory days.
For the foreseeable future I suggest Performance buyers longing for perfection place their order with Tesla if your budget allows. But for friends and family seeking sustainable transportation with a personal flair at a more reasonable price point, I happily endorse the new Swedish upstart Polestar 2 without significant compromises. Things only improve exponentially from here electrifying transportation for a better planetary future.
Did I overlook any comparisons helpful to your own purchasing decision between these amazing machines? Sound off below or email me at [email protected] with data requests. Want to take one out for a spin? Reach out and I’m happy show you why I’m so bullish behind the wheel.
