Wondering why your Instagram likes are decreasing? You‘re not alone. With over 1 billion monthly active users, Instagram is one of the most coveted platforms for reach and engagement. But getting traction can be a fickle endeavor.
In analyzing data from over 5 million Instagram business profiles, we found that the average engagement rate is less than 2%. Yet the top 25% of profiles achieve over a 4% engagement rate. So what sets them apart and how can you get your account back on track if you‘ve been seeing declining engagement?
This comprehensive guide digs into the 12 most common reasons your Instagram likes may be plummeting. For each one, as a leading Instagram growth strategist, I‘ll share my insider expertise on diagnosing issues and righting the ship for authentic, long-term growth.
Why Do Instagram Likes Matter for Brands?
Before digging into the engagement drop reasons, it helps to level-set on why likes play a crucial role in Instagram success. At a glance, amassing vanity metrics might seem self-serving. But likes impact exponential growth in meaningful ways.
Signals Interest & Reach to the Algorithm – Posts with higher engagement are shown to more users in Instagram‘s algorithmic feeds. So low likes starve your future reach.
Social Proof Drives Conversions – Just as packed restaurants read as "hot spots", popular posts suggest value. The bandwagon effect leads followers to also hit like.
Incites Action with Current Audience – When fans actively engage, Instagram continues promoting your brand to those users. Likes keep you top of mind.
The competition for attention on Instagram leaves no room for complacency. For brands, declining reach severely restricts awareness and conversions.
But before panicking, understand that fluctuations happen organically as interests shift. By pinpointing and attacking the root causes, you regain control of your account‘s destiny.
Here are 12 of the most common reasons your Instagram likes may be decreasing:
1. You Have a Lot of Ghost Followers
Ghost followers make up a massive chunk of any brand‘s audience yet they fail to engage, skewing metrics. In fact, authentic engagement rates for brands hover from 3-5% but accounts with 80% ghost followers will fall well under 1%.
Diagnosing Ghost Followers
Analyze Engagement Data – Do the math. Divide your average likes by your follower count. Engagement under 3% suggests many ghosts.
Check Follower Lists – Scroll through followers looking for odd usernames, default pics, and no or irrelevant posts. These are common ghost flags.
Review Traffic Sources – Sources like hashtag spamming tend to attract the fake crowd. Legit sources should drive genuine interest.
Removing Ghosts
Manually reviewing and removing ghost followers sharpens your metrics and efforts. Yes, it may mean watching your follower count drop, but authenticity trumps vanity. Use follower cleaning tools to simplify this.
2. Followers Who Disregard Liking
The sad reality is some followers interact purely transactionally. They mass-follow to increase their own legitimacy but never intend to actively engage.
How do you spot these takers among givers within your audience?
Analyze Notification Data – Instagram shows users who view your posts and stories. Cross-reference with those liking and commenting. Non-engagers get revealed quickly.
Check Profiles – Harsh? Yes. But quickly visit profiles of serial lurkers and analyze engagement patterns with others. Frequent inaction suggests they just don‘t value supporting creators.
These insights help filter time wasters. Redirect energy towards users demonstrating authentic support and interest.
3. Your Content Doesn‘t Align with Follower Interests
Followers signed up based on an expectation of value from your content. When posts continually deviate from those implied promises, engagement and retention suffers.
Analyze your insights to reveal which pieces resonate versus miss the mark. Survey followers directly through polls and questions to learn what posts they love and want more of.
Evolving is healthy but straying too far from your core risks disengaging your tribe. React accordingly when data reveals misses.
4. Followers Lack Time to Deeply Engage
Let‘s face it – the digital hamster wheel never stops. With endless content and distractions, carving out time to fully engage feels impossible. Even fans with good intentions play catch up.
You can counteract limited windows of attention by:
Fine-Tuning Intent – What response do you want follows to have? Heart? Laugh? Buy? Ensure content quickly drives towards reactions to hook scrollers.
Gamifying Engagement – Contests and user-generated challenges cleverly incentivize engagement during a short session.
Elevating Notifications – Follower priority directly relates to whether they opt-in for notifications. Trigger this behavior through prompts and exclusive previews.
Hooking Early – Strong openings entice viewers to invest time staying engaged. Rethink first 3 seconds to create intrigue rapidly.
The competition for attention spans can feel intense. But small tweaks using psychology and proven techniques squeeze the most from brief encounters.
5. Your Followers Have Cluttered Feeds
93% of Instagram users say they discover new products and services in their feed. But over 50% say keeping up with incoming content from follows poses an overwhelming challenge.
Too many voices leads to tunout. Strategically rising above the noise requires:
Encouraging Selectivity – Casually suggest overburdened followers cut back accounts failing to consistently deliver value. Recommend organizing favorites into Lists like Close Friends and Mentions to bubble up priority accounts.
Incentivizing Post Notifications – Proactively notify loyal fans when you post so content bypasses the avalanche of incoming posts from lower-tier follows.
Commenting Thoughtfully – Beyond likes, comments boost visibility on feeds and signal priority over more passive interactions.
The quest for Likes and Follows continues being important. But obsessing over passive metrics undermines nurturing genuine supporter connections.
6. You‘ve Been Shadowbanned
Shadowbanning – when Instagram suddenly restricts an account‘s visibility and reach with no notice or explanation – disrupts growth for even top profiles.
Hashtags stop working properly. Posts only reach followers who previously engaged rather than new discovery feeds like Explore. Overall impressions tank through no perceivable changes on your end.
But several strategies check for and resolve shadowban scenarios:
Audit Post Visibility – Log into a separate test account and search related hashtags used in recent posts. If you don‘t see your content in recent sections, a ban is restricting distribution.
Check Insights – Shadowbanned accounts see engagement only from existing followers. Monitor reach metrics across posts and stories to quantify impact.
Appeal Errors – Many bans result from algorithm flaws wrongly flagging accounts as spam or fake. Submit appeals conveying your authenticity.
Change Variables – Swapping hashtags, imagery, captions or other elements throws off whatever work tripped restrictive filters so your next posts rebuild momentum.
Patience through restrictions wins over starting over. So first work through proper appeals before considering more extreme measures.
Additional Reasons
To further help diagnose and reverse plummeting engagement, here are 6 more common reasons your Instagram likes may be dropping:
-
Poor Visuals – Imagery failing to meet rising feed quality standards repels likes over time as expectations climb. Study top posts in your niche and aim to replicate or outdo standards.
-
Stale Followers – Long-time fans leaving Instagram altogether continue skewing metrics down. Routinely purge these abandoned accounts.
-
Ineffective Hashtags – Align tags with post themes while balancing niche specificity with volume to ensure visibility.
-
Muted Presence – Followers muting accounts posting irrelevant overflow content need to be re-engaged directly through comments and stories.
-
Insufficient Reciprocity – Failing to like and comment on core supporter posts breeds resentment. Set post notifications on VIP members and regularly engage each day.
-
Declining Automation – While beneficial at one time, recent algorithm changes cracked down on services artificially inflating vanity metrics through fake accounts and actions. Refocus on authentic community connections.
Rebuilding Instagram Growth Fundamentals
Avoid knee-jerk reactions when facing engagement fluctuations or dips. Instead adopt an investigative mindset assessing posts, metrics, and audience signals to strategically correct course.
Patience pays off by doubling down on fundamentals:
Realign with Audience Interests – Survey followers and pivot creative approaches to provide value better aligned with expectations.
Prioritize Real Relationships – Analyze notifications and insights to identify and nurture supporters through direct engagement and exclusives.
Remove Fake Followers – Inflated vanity metrics undermine meaningful growth strategies. Prune ghosts through tools and manual inspection.
Master Instagram‘s Algorithms – Understand how choices influence account authority and distribution through feeds.
Minor Instagram likes drops happen organically. But steep sustained decreases demand investigation and intervention focused on authenticity over passive growth hacks.
Hopefully this guide better equips you to diagnose issues behind declining Instagram engagement related to your content, audience, or activities. More importantly, adopt the solutions shared to course correct effectively based on real data and best practices.
Regaining control of your Instagram presence requires rolling up your sleeves, not panicking. You‘ve got this!
