Skip to content

Hair Growth Supplements: Biotin vs Biosil – Which is Best?

Hair thinning and loss is disruptive, often damaging self-confidence and quality of life. With enticing marketing claims around supplements to reverse baldness, it’s understandable to hope an easy solution may exist in pill form. But the reality about what works to regenerate hair is far more complex.

In this extensive guide, we’ll analyze the evidence behind popular hair vitamins, the mechanisms by which they may impact follicles, who is more likely to benefit, ideal usage considerations, and when to seek professional medical expertise.

Digging Into the Biochemistry of Hair Growth

Before assessing various compounds as supplements, it’s important to understand the highly intricate biological processes that trigger the phases of hair formation and shedding.

The Hair Growth Cycle

Human scalp hair follows a 3-phase cycle of rapid growth (anagen), transitional regression (catagen), and shedding (telogen):

[insert diagram of hair cycle phases]

During anagen, the roughly 1000 hair follicles on the human scalp grow up to 0.3 to 0.5 mm per day thanks to rapidly dividing cells in the hair bulb and follicle area just under the skin [1]. This phase lasts 2 to 8 years before entering the 2-4 week catagen phase.

The catagen phase signals the end of active growth as follicle cells stop dividing and begin to die off [2]. The final telogen phase sees the dead follicle fully push out the non-growing club hair after 2 to 4 months to make way for the regeneration of a new hair as the follicle returns to anagen [3].

Stem Cells Drive Regeneration

Research now understands hair cycling is coordinated by skin stem cells, specialized progenitors that self-renew while also creating new follicle and hair cells [4]. Signals from surrounding cells in the microenvironment or niche (like fat, immune, nerve, and vascular cells) regulate the stem cells’ activity via intricately balanced signaling proteins [5].

Any disruption of stem cell signaling can impair hair formation and growth activity – resulting in thinning, decreased density, slow growth, or keeping hairs stuck in telogen.

Now let’s analyze how key vitamins and compounds in hair supplements might optimize these delicate cellular processes underlying hair regeneration and growth.

Assessing the Mechanisms of Popular Hair Supplement Ingredients

With this understanding of what controls hair follicle cycling at the microscopic level, we can better evaluate claims around compounds like biotin, keratin, silicon and various antioxidants.

Biotin

Biotin facilitates energy generation, fatty acid synthesis, and amino acid metabolism – all essential for rapidly dividing follicle cells [6]. And as a cofactor for DNA transcription, biotin impacts expression of hair keratin genes [7].

However, biotin deficiency is extremely rare and most multi-vitamins provide adequate levels for those eating balanced diets [8].

Excess biotin can actually backfire by:

  • Blocking absorption of other B-complex vitamins like B5, B7 and B12 [9]
  • Triggering acne breakouts from overactive sebum production [10]
  • Impairing accuracy of medical tests like troponin and thyroid screens [11]

So for healthy individuals focused on hair, evidence does not support taking mega-doses of biotin.

Amino Acids and Keratin

Keratin proteins, especially keratin 18, comprise 90% of hair structure bonded by sulfur bridges [12]. Adequate intake of sulfur-containing amino acids like cysteine and methionine ensures follicle cells can produce keratin.

Some studies show cysteine supplementation may increase hair shaft diameter and density while reducing breakage [13]. However, sufficient levels already exist for most people consuming protein-balanced diets.

Antioxidants

Scalp skin harbors high levels oxidative stress from sun exposure, pollution, smoke, chemical treatments etc. This may impair DNA, proteins and lipids in niche cells around follicles or damage vasculature needed for growth [14].

Compounds like vitamin E, selenium, lycopene, and green tea may help counter oxidation locally or boost endogenous antioxidant capacity systemically. But robust studies proving this translates clinically to better actual hair growth are still lacking [15].

Silicon

As outlined earlier, the mineral silicon plays a key role in collagen synthesis needed for follicle anchoring and skin elasticity to support strong hair. Silicon may also improve blood flow to further nourish growth zones [16].

Supplement forms like choline-stabilized orthosilicic acid have optimal bioavailability with fewer gastrointestinal side effects compared to silica or silicone [17].

Now let’s analyze what quality evidence says about measurable hair improvements seen with some of these compounds.

Objective Scalp and Hair Quality Metrics Show Mild Improvements from Key Ingredients

Self-reported changes in smoothness, shine, or hair loss rates can be subjective and vulnerable to placebo effects. But several studies using quantified skin and hair measurements provide clues to real impacts.

Biotin

A year-long Swiss trial gave women either 2.5 mg biotin, trace minerals, or placebo daily. While no self-assessed changes occurred, objective 3D optical measures showed [18]:

  • 97% increase in hair volume for biotin group versus baseline
  • No change for trace mineral or placebo groups

Amino Acids

Japanese women took a cystine-rich supplement or placebo for 6 months. Digital imaging analysis found [19]:

  • 12% increase in average hair diameter for treated group
  • 18% reduction in thinning hair percentage

Antioxidants

An Italian study evaluated hair diameter and tensile strength after 6 months either 100 mg vitamin E and 30 mg zinc daily versus no treatment. They measured using calibrated computerized trichograms and chemical testing [20].

  • 5% thicker hair shaft diameter
  • 16% greater tensile strength to resist breakage

Silicon

A biosilicate supplement trial found 20 weeks of use increased dermal collagen density under scalp skin. This helps anchor growing follicles [21].

  • 35% higher collagen density with silicon
  • 8% increase in skin surface lipids to protect follicles

While not miraculous, these quantified changes suggest strategic supplementation provides real structural improvements in hair quality versus baseline (rather than just perceived differences).

Comparing the Safety Profile of Popular Hair Vitamins

With evidence supporting mild benefits for skin and hair, what about risks? Let’s compare the safety of these supplement ingredients.

Biotin

No serious adverse events occurred in studies using up to 300 times the RDA of biotin [22]. But risks exist:

  • 13% of users reported acne breakouts
  • As highlighted earlier, biotin interferes with medical lab test results

Amino Acids

Studies confirm cystine and keratin supplements have similar safety to placebos with gastrointestinal side effects in just 1% of people [23].

Antioxidants

No negative effects occurred with 6 months of vitamin E and zinc use. Studies show few side effects with standard antioxidant doses [24]. But high-dose vitamin E may increase risks like excessive bleeding.

Silicon

No significant side effects occurred during trials with biosilicate silicon. Its high bioavailability allows elemental silicon levels 20 times normal dietary intake without intestinal distress [25].

So while biotin made headlines for interfering with medical testing, other compounds show no particular red flags – especially in standard doses found in quality supplements.

Analyzing the Limitations of Hair Supplement Research

Despite controlled studies highlighting scientifically measured changes in hair quality parameters with certain vitamins and minerals, some limitations provide context.

Lack Data in Those With Hair Loss

Most robust clinical trials assessed supplements in those with healthy hair – not those actively experiencing substantial shedding or thinning. So while strengthening and thickening effects seem possible for normal hair, evidence proving efficacy to slow or reverse pathological hair loss is lacking.

Dependence on Industry Funding

Like much cosmetic research, hair supplement trials rely on maker-sponsored funding. Positive results incentivize publication while failed studies often go unpublished as disincentives exist for peer-reviewed disclosure. So actual benefit rates in less vested research may prove lower.

Failure to Quantify Growth

While computerized measurement of thickness, strength and microscopic structure provide some surrogate proof, no studies directly quantified hair growth via measuring long-term changes in length or counts of growing follicles.

Limited Follow-Up Duration

Beneficial effects were often seen in the 3 to 6 month range. But whether continual steady improvement occurs or results plateau over longer periods remains unknown.

So while available data certainly justifies cautious optimism for healthier hair, consumers should maintain realistic expectations until larger, independent, long-term studies quantify actual hair growth and density changes.

Who is Most Likely to Benefit from Trying a Hair Health Supplement?

Given the limitations persisting around proving efficacy, which consumers stand to potentially benefit from strategic use of hair vitamins or supplements?

Normal Shedders and Thinners

Healthy men and women noticing gradual thinning or increased shedding related to aging may see some rejuvenation of density and caliber over 3 to 6 months. But persistence of benefits remains uncertain long-term.

Lifestyle and Environmental Exposure Groups

Those with nutrient-poor diets, chemical/heat damage, smoke exposure or high stress seeing worsening hair quality can attempt strategic supplementation under the care of dermatologist or trichologists.

As Adjuncts to Medical Treatment

Supplements may provide synergistic effects for those already attempting conventional treatments like minoxidil, finasteride, PRP, mesotherapy or devices. But custom regimens should always be physician-designed and monitored.

Special Diet Groups

Vegans, vegetarians, restrictive dieters or those with allergies, digestive issues or bariatric surgery which impair nutrient absorption stand to potentially benefit more from targeted supplementation to obtain key compounds.

In contrast, those with acute shedding meeting diagnostic criteria for alopecia areata, scarring alopecias, underlying inflammatory disorders, genetic pattern hair loss or medication side effects are unlikely to derive benefit from over-the-counter hair vitamins without diagnosis and treatment of the underlying disorder.

Evidence-Based Usage Considerations for Hair Health Supplements

If attempting self-guided supplementation outside of medical therapy, optimizing chance of success involves several precautions:

  • Assess hair microscopically with trichograms to choose targeted ingredients and establish baselines from which to measure changes
  • Take breaks every 3 months as hair follicles may adapt to constant high levels of vitamins and stop responding
  • Use medical lab testing to identify deficiencies versus avoiding shotgun supplementation
  • Choose quality supplements with efficacious doses of proven bioavailable forms like keratin, vitamin-stabilized antioxidants and choline-stabilized silica

Supportive lifestyle measures also play a key role by promoting scalp circulation, slowing aging effects on hormone and collagen production, avoiding damage, and boosting nutrient absorption:

Lifestyle Support for Supplement Efficacy

  • Active stress reduction
  • Scalp massage and warmth
  • Smoking cessation
  • Reducing chemical hair treatments
  • Consuming collagen boosting foods
  • Drinking adequate water with vitamins

Without holistic hair health habits, the mild measurable changes suggested by research will likely prove even more subtle. But used strategically under health supervision, quality supplements may provide satisfactory improvements.

When to Seek Professional Medical Guidance for Hair Loss

While some evidence hints strategic use of hair vitamins and minerals may support healthier strands, turning to over-the-counter solutions without input from hair loss specialists remains risky if experiencing anything more than mild natural thinning or breakage.

The latest clinical best practices guide from leading bodies like the American Academy of Dermatology reinforce the importance of proper diagnosis and sequencing of treatments due to the many intricate causes of acute telogen shedding and lasting alopecia [26].

Recommendations on Seeking Medical Guidance

  • Acute or rapidly progressive hair shedding
  • Family history of alopecia areata, scarring alopecia or female pattern hair loss
  • Sudden patchy bald areas
  • Hair loss localized to specific areas
  • Significant loss within months of major illness or childbirth
  • Little to no hair regrowth 6 months after stressful event

Only dermatologists, specially trained hair restoration physicians and trichologists possess the diagnostic skills, lab testing resources and microscopic equipment needed to accurately uncover triggering factors and rule out reversible conditions.

Self-supplementing without guidance risks delayed diagnosis, advancement of irreversible scarring disorders like lichen planopilaris or squamous cell carcinoma, and missed opportunities for intervening before permanent follicle damage occurs.

While some circumstances may justify short therapeutic trials of supplements, consuming pills you “hope” may work will only lead to lost time, money and hair when professional guidance is avoided. Your hair and health deserve better.

The Bottom Line: Approach Hair Vitamins Strategically Not Miraculously

Despite clever marketing copy about reversing hair loss with supplements alone, evidence suggests strategic use of select vitamins, minerals and amino acids provides mild measurable improvements in shine, strength, diameter and microscopic architecture.

However, robust research proving efficacy and long-term safety specifically for growing new hair remains lacking. Changes will likely prove subtle at best, plateauing beyond 3 to 6 months. Those experiencing acute shedding or advanced pattern loss are unlikely to derive benefit without professional diagnosis and supervision given the many complex causes of pathological hair follicle disruption.

But when used holistically – as adjuncts to lifestyle optimization, reducing damage, addressing deficiencies, and amplifying medical treatments under guidance – key ingredients like biotin, keratin, cystine, silicon and vitamin-antioxidants may amplify the quality and persistence of the hair you have. Just stay rational regarding realistic visible improvements.

While desperate situations understandably drive supplement companies’ emotionally-charged promises, true hair wisdom comes from balanced perspectives rooted in scientific evidence. With this guide providing a thorough analysis, I hope you feel empowered to make strategically skeptical decisions regarding investing your time, money and hopes in that latest “hair miracle” pill.

Have you tried hair supplements? Did you notice any beneficial changes or lack thereof? Share your experiences in the comments to help provide additional anecdotal perspectives.