Introduction: Fitbit‘s Stellar Smartwatch Lineup
Founded in 2007 as an early pioneer in wearables, Fitbit has grown into a globally recognized lifestyle brand synonymous with health metrics and activity tracking. Fitbit‘s lineup covers both leading-edge smartwatches like the Sense 2 along with more affordable fitness bands such as the Inspire series.
Sitting right in the middle are two recent releases catering to different audiences but offering compelling value – the Fashion-focused Luxe and high-performance Charge 5. Let‘s see how these two mid-range models compare.
Target Users and Positioning
The Fitbit Luxe caters predominantly to style-conscious consumers wanting a fashionable band that blends from gym to office. Given its slender jewelry-inspired design, the Luxe particularly appeals to women looking for a feature-packed tracker that works as a discreet bracelet replacement.
In contrast, the Charge 5 is Fitbit‘s flagship among hardcore athletes and health metric devotees. With its sportier build, it appeals more to men along with active women craving robust performance stats.
Priced at $149 and $179 respectively, both models offer impressive capabilities considering discounts available on predecessor bands like the Charge 4, Charge 3, and Inspire 2.
Side-by-Side Spec Comparison
Digging into the spec sheets reveals a great deal about the strengths of each wearable. Let‘s compare them across the most important categories:
| Specs | Fitbit Luxe | Fitbit Charge 5 |
|---|---|---|
| Release Date | April 2021 | September 2021 |
| Retail Price | $149.95 | $179.95 |
| Frame Material | Brushed stainless steel | Anodized aluminum |
| Band Material | Silicone or soft-gold stainless link | Silicone or athletic sport |
| Accessory Bands Available | Multiple Luxe Special Edition designs | Charge sport bands & premium Horween leather |
| Display Technology | AMOLED touchscreen | Brighter AMOLED, supports always-on mode |
| Display Size | 0.76" x 0.4" (124 x 206 pixels) | Slightly larger at 0.86” x 0.44” |
| Pixel Density | 339 ppi | ~300 ppi |
| Sensors | Optical HR, SpO2, Accelerometer | Adds EDA, ECG, Skin Temp, Allergen |
| Special Features | Fashion jewelry design | Daily Readiness Score, GPS, NFC Payments |
| Water Resistance Rating | Up to 164 feet (5 ATM) | Matching waterproofing up to 164 feet |
| Onboard + Connected GPS | Connected GPS | Built-in GPS + GLONASS |
| Wireless Connectivity | Bluetooth 5.0 | Bluetooth 5.1 + NFC |
| Fitness Tracking Modes | 20+ exercises like walks, runs & swims | Adds GPS-based pace & distance for 40+ |
| Battery Life Estimates | 5 days | Longer at over 7 days |
| Quick Charging | 0 to 100% in 2 hours | Same 0-100% recharge in 2 hours |
Analyzing the table confirms the Charge 5 justifies its higher pricing with extra hardware like onboard GPS, NFC payments and more advanced sensor package. However, most buyers find the Luxe‘s fashionable yet capable feature set provides excellent value matched by few competitors.
Design Showdown: High Fashion Meets Sporty Chic
Style conscious shoppers will likely gravitate to the Luxe’s elegant design in platinum, soft gold and graphite finishes. Its slender flattened casing resembles a fine bracelet with a discreet rectangular display. Enhanced Durability featuring Gorilla Glass 3 helps it retain polished metal shine despite daily wear.
Conversely, the Charge 5 embraces a sportier look with its solid machined aluminum frame and lightweight removable silicone bands in black, white or blue. The module stands off your wrist allowing the skin to breathe for long workouts. And the selection of premium Horween leather accessory bands dress up the tracker for post-workout functions.
So if you want daily jewelry suitable for the office that also tracks steps, the Luxe perfectly fills that void. But for optimizing hardcore workouts with GPS pace and distance, the Charge 5 has the function and form factor to match.
Health & Activity Tracking
Both Fitbit models provide extensive metrics perfect for optimizing your health and hitting new PBs. Let‘s compare what insights each device captures.
Heart rate Tracking
Each uses Fitbit‘s excellent PurePulse technology to monitor your beating heart 24/7. See your heart rate zone in real-time during exercise and view trends over time through heart rate variability. The Charge 5 extends monitoring further by sending high/low notifications when irregular rhythms occur. And its built-in ECG app (pending FDA clearance in the US) screens for atrial fibrillation by examining heart electrical signals when activated.
All-day activity monitoring & sleep tracking
Thanks to 3-axis accelerometers in each tracker, your daily steps, distance, calories burned and hourly movement prompts are all visible in the Fitbit app. Both also automatically log exercise sessions like walks, runs and swims. When sleeping, accelerometer data combines with heart rate patterns to determine sleep time, stages (Light, Deep, REM), and overall sleep score.
Next-gen health insights
This is where the Charge 5 stretches far beyond the Luxe. In addition to everything the Luxe offers, the Charge 5 provides a "Daily Readiness Score" to optimize your training – lower means to focus on recovery, while higher suggests your body can handle more strain. This score considers sleep, heart rate variability and recent exercise load. For detailed personalization, subscribe to Fitbit Premium to incorporate your personal baseline fitness and health biometrics.
Three other exclusive Charge 5 sensors also provide deeper health insights:
-
EDA sensor tracks electrodermal activity interpreting stress responses from tiny electrical skin changes
-
SpO2 sensor measures blood oxygen saturation levels during both exercise and sleep
-
Skin temperature sensor detects variations influencing health and sleep
So if you just seek basic tracking and step milestones, the Luxe suffices. But hungry data nerds will certainly appreciate next-level insights only the Charge 5‘s advanced array of 8 biometric sensors empowers.
Built-in GPS for Outdoor Activity Tracking
The Charge 5 also stands out by incorporating both GPS and GLONASS satellite systems enabling it to precisely track pace, distance and routes for outdoor runs and rides without carrying a phone. The Charge 5 tracks over 40 different exercises and even without GPS still covers essentials like yoga, pilates strength training and more by leveraging motion and heart rate.
The Luxe favors slim aesthetics over GPS, hence relying fully on connected GPS functionality by tethering to your phone’s location services. So phone-free tracking accuracy does suffer slightly. But for most users, the elegance, 5-day battery and lower cost help offset this limitation.
Smart Features Beyond Just Fitness
In terms of all-day smart features, both fitness bands help you effortlessly manage notifications, quickly respond to messages from your wrist and control phone music playback. Let‘s outline these helpful extras that accompany the premium health tracking abilities.
Notifications
No matter which tracker you choose, incoming calls, texts, calendar alerts and updates from apps conveniently appear directly on your wrist so you needn‘t reach for your phone. Both allow quick replies to SMS messages and messenger apps if paired with Android phones. For iPhone users, preset quick replies let you respond to incoming texts and messenger alerts.
Music Playback Controls
The workout-optimized Charge 5 and fashionable Luxe both offer convenient music controls including the ability to start, stop, skip tracks and adjust volume when listening on your phone. Just don‘t expect onboard music storage or streaming over LTE on either model.
NFC Payments
One exclusive feature offered by the Charge 5 is Fitbit Pay for contactless payments using your tracker. After entering your payment cards into the Wallet section of the Fitbit app, you can securely tap to pay at any checkout terminals accepting NFC payments. Given the Luxe‘s priority on sleek aesthetics, contactless payments unfortunately didn‘t make the features cut.
Apps and Clock Faces
While app catalogs don‘t compare to full-fledged smartwatches, both the Luxe and Charge 5 allow installing additional apps and on-device clock face customization through the Fitbit Gallery store. Further personalize your tracker to your tastes without significantly diminishing that 5+ day battery runtime.
So in summary, both models cover the essential smart features you’d expect like notifications and music controls. But with built-in GPS for tracking and NFC for payments, the Charge 5 does push smart functionality a bit further overall.
Battery Life and Charging
Despite its slim silhouette, the Luxe still packs an impressive 5 days of runtime even with moderate usage like workout tracking and daily notifications. For those who disable more battery-hungry features like always-on display and notifications, stretching to over week is feasible.
The Charge 5 bests the slim Luxe with a claimed 7-day max lifespan or 5 days with more frequent GPS and workout usage. This does mean less frequent charging with once a week generally sufficient.
Both Fitbits fully recharge from 0 to 100% in about 2 hours. So even if you do deplete them completely, juice them up while getting ready in the morning or unwinding before bed.
Pros and Cons Comparison
Fitbit Luxe Pros:
- Attractive slim jewelry design wears comfortably 24/7
- Sharp AMOLED display readable even in sunlight
- Robust sleep, steps, heart rate & workout tracking
- 5 day battery life for weekly charging convenience
- Included 6-month Fitbit Premium trial
Fitbit Luxe Cons:
- Lack of onboard GPS limits tracking accuracy
- Smaller display challenging to read mid-workout
- Occasional lags when navigating touchscreen
- Can stretch or stain pricier stainless steel bands
Fitbit Charge 5 Pros:
- Built-in GPS for maximizing pace & distance accuracy
- Multi-day 7+ day battery life
- Added sensors like EDA, ECG provide deeper health insights
- Brighter always-on display quick glances during exercise
- Fitbit Pay for contactless payments without your phone or wallet
Fitbit Charge 5 Limitations:
- Sporty functional design less stylish for 24/7 wear
- Touchscreen responsiveness occasionally lags
- High price point of $179.95
- Some features require Fitbit Premium subscription
Verdict – Which Model Should You Buy?
So is the flagship Charge 5 worth $30 extra over the fashion-oriented Luxe? The right tracker depends primarily on your personal activity tracking and style preferences.
Choose the Luxe for:
Everyday Allure – With its slender polished bracelet-style design and comfortable band, the Luxe outshines in 24/7 subtle elegance.
Running Essentials – Even without onboard GPS, the Luxe accurately captures pace, distance and heart rate for walks, runs, swims and 20+ more exercises by tethering to your phone‘s GPS.
5-Day Battery Runtime – Typical users enjoy a full week between charges while still tracking activity, sleep and notifications.
Splurge on the Charge 5 for:
Maximizing Outdoor Accuracy – Built-in GPS plus GLONASS satellite support ensures precise pace, distance and mapping without carrying your phone.
Robust Health Stats – Additional sensors like EDA for stress, SpO2 for blood oxygen and skin temp provide deeper health insights to optimize your exercise and recovery.
7-Day+ Battery Life – With light usage, enjoy over a week before recharging thanks to a more capacious battery than the Luxe.
So choose the jewelry-resembling Luxe to effortlessly incorporate activity tracking into your stylish everyday wear. But upgrade to the Charge 5 if you crave maximum workout optimization through built-in GPS, advanced biometrics and 7 days of runtime. Either way you‘ll shine with whichever high-performing Fitbit tracker you select!
