The Notorious Mystery: Why We Still Obsess Over the Murders of Hip Hop Icons
In 1996 and 1997, rap lost two pivotal stars to violence: Tupac Shakur and Christopher “Biggie Smalls” Wallace. The slain superstars left behind musical legacies still revered today. Yet their unavenged deaths rank among music’s most agonizing unsolved mysteries, feeding an ongoing blame game among fans and conspiracy theorists accusing everyone from crooked cops to billion-dollar hip hop players.
Now one mogul finds himself again in the hot seat amid resurrected speculation about his role in the saga: Sean “Diddy” Combs. Already trailed by old rumors, fresh accusations sparked by another hip hop titan have spurred new scrutiny of the impresario’s links to the infamous killings.
To understand why these cold cases still incite so much heated debate, you need look no further than their shocking brutality, criminal sophistication, and uncanny symmetry. But most compelling is what the twin slayings robbed music fans of at a transcendent moment in rap’s coming of age: the full flowerings of two superstar talents whose bold rhymes resonated far beyond beats and bars to give voice to struggling communities.
Even a quarter century later, we are haunted by the magnitude of what was lost when those bullets took two lives on the cusps of global fame. We still cry out for answers and accountability. We still feel [Tupac and Biggie’s] absences, even as hip hop has conquered the mainstream thanks to visionaries like Combs. And we still believe homicide victims – especially those of immense talent and cultural sway like these – deserve the due justice too long denied.
Two Torso Shots Topple Rap Royalty
When Tupac was struck down at 25, hip hop was just reaching mass consciousness and commercial heights. Annual rap music revenues [jumped from $750 million in 1995 to over $2 billion by 2000]. Pac embodied an aggressive and gritty offshoot nicknamed “gangsta rap,” portrayed as fueling violence even as its stars denounced oppression of impoverished Black communities. His smash album All Eyez On Me spent months in the top ten when it was released months before he was gunned down in a Las Vegas drive-by in September 1996.
Just six months later, a strikingly similar assassination in Los Angeles took Biggie Smalls, rap’s East Coast counterpoint to Tupac’s West Coast figurehead status. Notorious B.I.G. had also just dropped a hotly anticipated sophomore album, Life After Death, which ruled the charts for months after the 24-year-old suffered the same brutal fate: killed by four .9mm slugs while sitting in an SUV.
The twin murders had all the hallmarks of targeted hits: both artists took torso shots at close range after the gunmen pulled up beside their vehicles. No valuables were stolen. The coldbloodedness of both crimes shook music fans to the core. And the similarities were impossible to ignore….
An East-West Schism Turns Lethal
Tupac’s sneering insults lobbed at East Coast rappers ratcheted up tensions between the two dominant hip hop locales. Pac’s provocative taunts lit a fuse under coastal rivalries that had been brewing as the traditionally NYC-centered genre exploded in popularity in the early 90s and spawned new stars in LA and elsewhere.
The escalating feuds grew increasingly personal after Shakur got shot five times in 1994 and blamed Biggie and his mentor Sean “Puffy” Combs. Months later, Tupac was convicted of sexual assault and sent to prison, stoking theories the charges were part of an East Coast smear campaign in retaliation for his jabs against Biggie and Diddy’s Bad Boy Records.
Pac took more swings on his 1995 album Me Against the World, recorded behind bars. His dis track “Hit Em Up” viciously taunted Biggie and his crew after Death Row Records head Suge Knight put up $1.4 million to spring Tupac from jail in 1995.
"That‘s why I fucked your bitch, you fat motherfucker," Pac raps, later threatening, “I‘ma kill you motherfucker.”
Many fans perceived those no-holds-barred provocations as directly responsible for Pac’s murder after he was shot on the Las Vegas strip on September 7, 1996. While some immediately assumed Biggie ordered the hit, conspiracy theories also swirled around Suge Knight….
Was Suge the Mastermind?
Marion “Suge” Knight cultivated Death Row Records’ notorious image built on intimidation tactics, legal scrutiny and rumors about its deep ties to LA street gangs like the Bloods and Crips. The burly, 6-foot-4 music executive had alleged gang associates working at his company and was steeped in a public feud with Sean Combs when Tupac was slain after the two attended a Mike Tyson boxing match.
Investigative journalist Chuck Phillips wrote extensively about Knight and Death Row’s strongarm tactics for the LA Times in articles later questioned for relies heavily on unnamed sources. But before his credibility took a hit, Phillips’s series framed Knight as a violent puppet master implicated in various crimes who likely conspired to take out Biggie to retaliate for Tupac’s murder.
“The root source of the Biggie Smalls murder goes back to Pac’s shooting in Las Vegas,” Phillips told NPR in 2002. “Suge Knight had apparently vowed to get revenge and to get ‘street justice‘ against the people involved in hurting Tupac.”
While Knight slammed these allegations, theories posit his foot soldiers in the Mob Piru Bloods carried out the vengeance killing on his behalf. An alleged Mob Piru hitman named Wardell “Poochie” Fouse died violently months after Biggie did, stoking beliefs he was the triggerman.
Yet Poochie was never conclusively tied to either rapper’s murder. And with Suge behind bars since 2015 on an unrelated charge, all focus has shifted back to the prime East Coast suspect since Tupac firstSONG lyrics revived conjecture about his role…
Eminem Disses Reignite Rumors
Like Pac did through his blistering rhymes, Eminem has mastered the art of stirring scandal through his own mastery: weaponized lyrics. Slim Shady’s latest lyrical grenade emerged on a leaked 2020 track targeting longtime antagonist Diddy:
"I know me and Khaled got it locked like Tupac was, Puffy know the truth so I don‘t know why he don‘t blast on you…," Em raps on "Zues," clearly accusing Diddy of hiding what he knows about Pac’s murder.
Stirring the pot further, Eminem references the rumor that Diddy pursued a tryst with Pac’s famous ex, provoking his fatal conflict with Biggie:
You know you fucked with Faith Evans, we know the reason you ‘Pac‘d up
Got knocked for your earrings and kill that era of rap for this!"
The explosive lyrics prompted a heated Instagram exchange between the superstar rappers. But just as with Tupac’s aggressive insults, some fans perceived Eminem’s latest jabs as dangerous fuel on a long-smoldering case.
Message board debates and Reddit threads fired up anew dissecting and defending theories about Diddy as a calculating kingpin. As one YouTube commenter asked: “How can Diddy be so rich and so powerful in the music industry and not know who killed Pac and Biggie?”
…