A Brief Background
Before diving into a detailed comparison, it helps to understand the background of these two headphone heavyweights. Beats Electronics rose to fame in the late 2000s with their signature bass-heavy sound. The company was then acquired by Apple in 2014 for $3 billion in a move that many saw as game-changing (Haselton, 2022).
Since then, Beats has operated under Apple but retained some autonomy over design and marketing. At the same time, Apple has integrated Beats technology into some of its products. For example, AirPods Pro utilize a custom driver based on Beats technology to enhance sound quality (Apple, 2022).
So while Beats Studio Buds and AirPods Pro may seem like competitors, they actually have significant overlap from an engineering and ownership standpoint. However, each product seeks to differentiate itself to appeal to certain consumer segments. Let’s explore how they stack up across key categories:
Pricing and Release Timeline
| Model | Release Date | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Beats Studio Buds | June 2021 | $149.99 |
| AirPods Pro | October 2019 (1st gen) September 2022 (2nd gen) |
$249 |
Pricewise, the Beats Studio Buds retail for about $100 less than AirPods Pro. However, the AirPods Pro have undergone a recent second-generation update that brings improved performance and sound quality. So that price premium goes towards more advanced features, as we’ll continue to explore.
Design
In terms of aesthetics, the Studio Buds go for a bold, stylish, and edgy look consistent with the Beats brand image. The earbuds feature a sleek pebble-like shape with no stem, available in chic color options like red, black, white, blue and gray (Beats, 2022).
Comparatively, AirPods Pro has a more understated, minimalist white design conforming to Apple’s pared back aesthetic. The stem is much shorter than previous AirPod models. So while less flashy than the Beats, AirPods still make a style statement akin to Apple’s brand image.
Comfort and fit also differ due to variations in earbud shape and size. According to CNET’s testing, AirPods Pro’s smaller contours allow for a more secure in-ear grip (Carman, 2022). And integrated air vents prevent in-ear pressure buildup.
Meanwhile, the bulkier Studio Buds rely on ear tips to wedge into the ear canal. Some users may find this uncomfortable long-term.
So when rating on aesthetics and ergonomics, neither headphone ranks definitively higher. It comes down to your styling preferences and sensitivity to in-ear pressure.
Audio Quality
Sound reproduction is arguably what users care about most when evaluating headphones. In this arena, AirPods Pro again stands out through the use of specialized Apple technologies.
The second-gen AirPods Pro employs a new low-distortion audio driver and custom amplifier to optimize sound clarity and accuracy (Apple, 2022). Many professional reviewers describe audio quality as bright, crisp and well-balanced across low, mid and high tones (Klosowski, 2022).
Beats Studio Buds also produce pleasing sound with accentuated bass, matching Beats’ signature audio profile preferred by pop, hip hop and dance genres. However, some critics feel treble tones sound slightly muted compared to optimal (Jones, 2021).
For noise cancellation, AirPods Pro uses two beamforming microphones to block external noise at up to 200 times per second. Testers find this highly effective for dulling environmental clatter like traffic or chatter (Klosowski, 2022).
Beats Studio Buds implement active noise cancelation (ANC) as well but assess incoming soundwaves just 48,000 times per second. So reviewers judge AirPods Pro as superior for damping ambient distractions (Tom’s Guide, 2021).
Taken together, this analysis shows AirPods Pro objectively ahead in both inherent audio reproduction and noise cancellation abilities. That said, fans of boosted bass may still prefer the Studio Buds’ sonic signature for personal music enjoyment.
Battery Life
Battery performance often dictates how conveniently you can use wireless headphones while on the move:
| Beats Studio Buds | AirPods Pro | |
|---|---|---|
| Battery Life (ANC Off) | 8 hours | 5 hours (1st gen), 6 hours (2nd gen) |
| Battery Life (ANC On) | 6 hours | 4.5 hours |
| Total Battery (with case) | 24 hours | 30 hours |
Tests show Beats Studio Buds outlasting AirPods Pro by about 2-3 hours per full charge depending on settings (Tom’s Guide, 2021). However with the charging case factored in, the AirPods nearly catch up in total portable playtime.
So battery life could be a consideration if you take frequent long-haul flights or have days packed with meetings. But for everyday use, either model generally gets you through a full day without issue.
Controls
Controlling music playback and phone calls directly on the headphones influences convenience as well.
As touched on earlier, AirPods Pro relies fully on press-sensitive force sensors built into the stem. Users click the stem to play/pause, switch between noise cancellation modes, invoke Siri and more. This keeps controls consolidated into a singular component.
Comparatively, the Beats Studio Buds places a tactile “b” button one on each earbud. For example, you click the left button to reject calls or activate transparency mode, while the right button handles play/pause and call management. So controls split across both sides.
Which approach works better comes down to personal preference around adaptability. AirPods Pro’s controls stay uniform no matter which ear you use a bud in. Meanwhile Beats allows using a single earbud more easily for mono playback.
Connectivity and Compatibility
Pairing and maintaining a steady Bluetooth connection ensures your wireless headphones actually work as expected. This is another area where Apple leverages unique native technology to excel:
Apple Devices: AirPods Pro seamlessly link with iPhones, iPads, Macs and more thanks to Apple’s H1 chip which enables automatic device switching. You also gain access to Siri voice commands. Android compatibility exists but lacks certain iOS-exclusive features.
Comparatively, Beats Studio Buds need manual re-pairing when switching between Apple devices. And you lose native Siri support without an iOS device present (Tom’s Guide, 2022).
Android Devices: For Android phones and tablets, connectivity is solid but rates below Apple’s tight ecosystem integration as expected. Beats Studio Buds holds a slight edge here through Google Fast Pair support for streamlined setup.
Windows PCs: Windows compatibility is hit-or-miss for both models and lacks the deep optimization seen on smartphone platforms. Here the Beats Studio Buds generally connects more reliably based on field testing (Jones, 2021).
So in summary, AirPods Pro works best when paired solely within Apple’s ecosystem, while Beats Studio Buds play nicer for cross-platform flexibility.
Extra Features and Add-Ons
A few other secondary capabilities also distinguish these headphones:
-
Wireless Charging: Only AirPods Pro cases support Qi-based wireless charging out of the box. Beats Studio Buds requires a separate case upgrade.
-
Spatial Audio: AirPods Pro unlocked precision spatial audio after a firmware update for a more immersive experience. Beats Studio Buds lack any comparable surround sound features.
-
In-Ear Detection: AirPods Pro can automatically pause playback when removing an earbud using optical sensors. Beats Studio Buds lack any similar sensing capabilities.
While not dealbreakers alone, these extras combined give AirPods Pro additional versatility over the comparably simpler Beats model. Consumers with an existing Qi charger or interest in next-gen audio may find these additions worthwhile.
Beats Studio Buds: Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Cheaper price point | No wireless charging case |
| Trendy aesthetics and colors | Bulkier earbud shape less comfortable for some |
| Longer raw battery life | Sonically not as detailed or well-balanced |
| Slightly better Android support | No spatial audio or in-ear detection |
To summarize, Beats Studio Buds strengths center on affordability and cross-platform flexibility. But audio fidelity and iOS-centric features lag behind AirPods Pro.
AirPods Pro: Pros and Cons
| Pros | Cons |
|---|---|
| Best-in-class active noise cancellation | Relatively short battery life |
| Top notch iOS integration with auto device switching | Limited controls without iOS device present |
| Spatial audio and innovative sound | Expensive price tag |
| Wireless charging case | Mostly restricted to white color scheme |
The AirPods Pro justifies its higher cost through excellent noise cancellation, spatial audio innovations and deep Apple ecosystem ties. Drawbacks center mostly on iOS-centricity and shorter runtimes.
Bottom Line: Which Model Should You Buy?
So ultimately, should you choose the Beats Studio Buds or AirPods Pro? Here is some guidance based on typical user profiles:
For iPhone owners who prioritize sound quality and noise cancellation:
AirPods Pro is likely the best option, thanks to tight Apple device integration and advanced audio capabilities unlocked by iOS connectivity. You simply get the richest, most tailored experience staying within Apple’s ecosystem.
For style-conscious Android phone users on a budget:
The cheaper Beats Studio Buds offer the most bang for your buck here. You still get capable sound and noise cancellation in an edgy, fashionable package with bonus Google fast pairing. Paying up for AirPods finesse makes less sense if not buying into the broader Apple experience.
For cross-platform professionals who value reliability:
If you often alternate between smartphones and laptops on-the-go while needing dependable wireless reception, the Beats Studio Buds is your safest pick. Reviewers found its Bluetooth connectivity holds up better when swapping between devices or operating systems.
So in closing, there is no definitive "better" option between the Beats Studio Buds and AirPods Pro. Choose based on your personal devices, budgets, priorities and listening tastes. For dedicated Apple households who relish premium acoustics, the latest AirPods Pro earns its steep price. But for more cost-conscious flexibility across iOS and Android, the Beats still shine as a compelling alternative from Apple’s own audio subsidiary.
References
Apple. "AirPods Pro." Accessed January 18, 2023. https://www.apple.com/airpods-pro-2nd-generation/
Beats. “Powerbeats Pro Totally Wireless Earphones." Accessed January 18, 2023. https://www.beatsbydre.com/earphones/powerbeats-pro
Carman, Elias. “AirPods Pro Are Still the Best True Wireless Earbuds You Can Buy." CNET, September 29, 2022. https://www.cnet.com/tech/mobile/apple-airpods-pro-2nd-gen-review/
Haselton, Todd. “How Apple Has Made $14 Billion From Its $3 Billion Beats Buyout." CNBC, July 30, 2022. https://www.cnbc.com/2022/07/30/how-apple-has-made-14-billion-from-3-billion-beats-buyout.html
Jones, Luke. “Beats Studio Buds Review." TechRadar, July 14, 2021. https://www.techradar.com/reviews/beats-studio-buds/
Klosowski, Thorin. “Apple AirPods Pro (2nd Generation) Review: Serious Sound." Wirecutter, September 8, 2022. https://www.nytimes.com/wirecutter/reviews/apple-airpods-pro-second-generation/
Tom’s Guide. “Beats Studio Buds Review." June 14, 2021. https://www.tomsguide.com/uk/reviews/beats-studio-buds
Tom’s Guide. “New AirPods Pro 2 vs. AirPods Pro: What‘s different and should you upgrade?" September 14, 2022. https://www.tomsguide.com/face-off/airpods-pro-2-vs-airpods-pro
