Skip to content

An In-Depth, Balanced Look at Genshin Impact‘s Game Design

Introduction

Genshin Impact is an action RPG with gacha monetization developed by the Chinese studio miHoYo. First released in 2020, it has gone on to become one of the most popular and lucrative games globally, with estimates of over $3 billion in lifetime revenue. However, Genshin finds itself the frequent target of criticism and negativity as well. This article will analyze Genshin‘s game design and business model in detail to understand both the ingenuity and controversies.

Genshin‘s Strengths

Captivating Open World Setting

Genshin features a sprawling open world known as Teyvat, comprised of seven distinct nations modeled after real-world cultures. Lush forests, imposing mountains, and glittering cities have all been realized with an impressive level of care and detail using miHoYo‘s proprietary game engine. Critics widely praise Genshin‘s vibrant visuals and environment design that make exploration compelling.

Slick Action RPG Combat

As an action RPG, combat is central to gameplay. Genshin implements a dynamic elemental combat system where players can mix and match element-themed characters to trigger powerful reactions. Battles are fast-paced affairs demanding skillful dodging and combos. The flexible team compositions enable varied strategies to suit different playstyles.

Memorable Musical Score

Accompanying the sights of the open world is an emotional, cinematic score that further enhances immersion. From epic orchestras to serene Chinese instruments, Genshin‘s music runs the gamut to match the mood and designs of each in-game nation. The soundtrack is entirely original and has won numerous awards since launch.

Constant Content Updates

While the main storyline wraps up rather quickly, miHoYo has committed to regular updates adding new regions, stories, characters, and events over time. Major updates arrive approximately every six weeks, providing steady new goals and challenges for endgame players. Five major nations have been added since launch, with at least two more planned.

Controversies Around Genshin‘s Design

However, Genshin also faces no shortage of criticism and negativity related to its monetization and repetitive, grind-heavy endgame. These polarizing elements contribute to why some players bounce off the experience.

Predatory Gacha Practices

The primary monetization comes from the gacha system where players spend premium currency called Primogems to obtain new characters and weapons randomly. While free earnable currency exists, the best items have notoriously low drop rates designed to incentive spending. Critics argue Genshin‘s gacha leverages gambling addiction and FOMO tactics to a predatory degree.

Excessive Late Game Grinding

Genshin‘s endgame progression system revolves around intense grinding. Maxing out characters requires collecting hundreds of upgrade materials by repeating daily quests and dungeons. The randomized artifact gear system also necessitates astronomical farming for good rolls. This neverending treadmill caters to hardcore players but risks burning out or frustrating casual fans.

Weak Narrative After Early Game

The main story quests and exceptional worldbuilding initially hook players. But the plot loses focus in later acts to instead emphasize limited time events and introducing new regions over advancing an overarching narrative. For fans drawn in by the early intriguing lore, this swerve to slice-of-life tangents disappoints.

Issues With Account Security

Controversy also stems from customer service struggles, especially regarding account security and recovery. The complex password and authentication requirements, combined with no official account linking, means permanently losing access is not uncommon. Critics describe customer service as unhelpful, demanding extensive hoop-jumping with little hope of restoration.

Evaluating Genshin‘s Balancing Act

Stepping back, Genshin Impact tries walking a tightrope, balancing compelling exploration and adventures with counseling players to spend more money and time. For some, the predatory monetization and repetitive grind sour the experience. For others, the rate of new content and engaging combat carries them through. Ultimately, Genshin‘s success indicates that while imperfect, miHoYo‘s vision clearly resonates with a massive audience.

Still, skepticism exists that trying to satisfy whales dropping thousands of dollars while avoiding burning out casual fans may prove an unsustainable long-term balance. As more regions and updates unroll, it remains to be seen whether Genshin can overcome its controversies to retain goodwill on both sides. MiHoYo faces challenging decisions on how far to double down on the current model versus making compromises to improve accessibility.

References